Are Nexus 6 models nearly impervious to the Voight-Kampff test, or very easy to spot?
Blade Runner seems to be unable to decide whether Nexus 6 Replicants are easy or hard to identify using the Voight-Kampff test. I'm wondering if there is a story explanation for this.
- Case 1: Leon (Brion James)
Leon is being tested in the first scene of the movie. Leon does very poorly: he interrupts with so many clarifying questions that the test administrator can barely get the first question out, and then he shoots the guy dead when the second question proves challenging.
Score: 1 question answered (probably failed that question)
- Case 2: Rachael (Sean Young)
Deckard tests Rachael at Tyrell's insistence: "I want to see a negative before I provide you with a positive." Even though Tyrell essentially states that Rachael is human, and Deckard says the test only needs 20-30 questions to identify a Replicant, he inexplicably asks three or four times as many questions. And when the test finally leads him to the answer that he was told not to expect, he's still uncertain enough that he states his conclusion as a question rather than a fact: "She's a Replicant, isn't she?"
Score: 100 questions answered (possibly 70+ answered satisfactorily)
Both Leon and Rachael are Nexus 6 Replicants (probably):
- While he briefs Deckard, Captain Bryant's computer screen states explicitly that Leon is a Nexus 6
- It is implied that Rachael is a Nexus 6, although the movie leaves enough wiggle room for her to be something else (Tyrell concedes that she is a Replicant and says she is "an experiment" but does not mention which generation, and Bryant's statement that "there is a Nexus 6 [at Tyrell's]" might refer to someone other than Rachael)
If Rachael is representative of Nexus 6 performance on the V/K test, then Leon should have performed similarly. Or, at least better than crashing and burning spectacularly.
Or, if Leon is representative of Nexus 6 V/K performance, then nobody should be worried that Nexus 6 models are difficult to detect, because they would not be. I actually think the movie gives us no choice but to believe that Leon did worse than a Nexus 5: since Nexus 6 is new, Deckard's expectation of 20-30 questions would be based on blade runners' experiences with older models.
It seems like the movie cannot make up its mind whether the Nexus 6 is comically handicapped like Leon, or supremely life-like (in the way that would be necessary to motivate the film's philosophical concerns).
Am I misinterpreting the evidence, or overlooking something? Is there a story explanation for this?
Best Answer
It's harder but not impossible to catch them using the VK test
As you state in the question, its clearly seen that Deckard correctly detects Rachael is a replicant, but it is significantly harder than usual:
Deckard: She's a replicant, isn't she?
Tyrell: I'm impressed. How many questions does it usually take to
spot them?
Deckard: I don't get it Tyrell.
Tyrell: How many questions?
Deckard: Twenty, thirty, cross-referenced.
Tyrell: It took more than a hundred for Rachael, didn't it?
However, I think you are mistaken in the assumption that Leon was failing the test badly, or is 'comically handicapped' in taking the test. With 20-30 questions normally needed, even a previous generation replicant would not have been found after 2 questions.
I think you are mistaking his behavior (confused, rambling) with behavior that would fail the test. It's not an intelligence test or a comprehension test, but one that tests for a human emotional response, both verbal and involuntary (skin conductivity and pupil dilation).
Leon is a model used for military and manual labor. He has infiltrated the company and is impersonating a "waste disposal engineer". His apparent confusion, lack of vocabulary (not knowing what a Tortoise is) may be genuine, but it is also possibly correct for him to be 'in character'.
He wouldn't fail the test not knowing what a tortoise is, or fail it by being confused, but he would fail if there was a consistent pattern of him not responding correctly (verbally or via the sensors detecting his physiological response) to 20-30 questions designed to provoke an emotional response.
Leon however clearly decides that he's going to be caught eventually and decides to surprise Holden and shoot him when he is not expecting it. Leon also may have already got enough information from the company and an opportunity to kill one of the people sent to find them would have been too good to miss.
I don't see this scene as being inconsistent with the premise that the Nexus-6 are harder to spot than previous generations of replicants.
Pictures about "Are Nexus 6 models nearly impervious to the Voight-Kampff test, or very easy to spot?"
What is the purpose of the Voight-Kampff test?
The Voight-Kampff test was a test used as of 2019 by the LAPD's Blade Runners to assist in determining whether or not an individual was a replicant. The test measured bodily functions such as respiration, heart rate, blushing and pupillary dilation in response to emotionally provocative questions.Is the Voight-Kampff real?
At the center of the question is a fictional test designed to distinguish between replicants and humans, called the Voight-Kampff test. It elicits emotions in the test subject that replicants supposedly can't have, then monitors physiological responses, like pupillary motion and reaction time.Does Deckard take the Voight-Kampff test?
Deckard takes the Voight-Kampff test and passes, confirming that he is a human. Harrison Ford, who played Deckard in the film, has said that he did not think Deckard is a replicant, and has said that he and director Ridley Scott had discussions that ended in the agreement that the character was human.Is the Voight-Kampff test a Turing test?
If a machine manages to deceive 30% of the judges, it will have passed the Turing Test. A variation of this test, devised by the mathematician Alan Turing in 1950, is the so-called Voight-Kampff Test, which is what the Blade Runners use to detect replicants.Blade Runner (1982) Deckard administers the Voight-Kampff test on Rachael
More answers regarding are Nexus 6 models nearly impervious to the Voight-Kampff test, or very easy to spot?
Answer 2
Not all Nexus-6s are alike.?In particular, Rachael has something that Leon and the others don't: memory implants.
TYRELL:?Rachael is an experiment, nothing more.?We began to recognise in them a strange obsession.?After all, they are emotionally inexperienced with only a few years in which to store up the experiences which you and I take for granted.?If we gift them with a past, we create a cushion or pillow for their emotions — and consequently we can control them better.
DECKARD:?Memories.?You're talking about memories.
As a result of this, while Leon and the others know they're replicants, during the test Rachael doesn't:
DECKARD:?She doesn't know?!
TYRELL:?She's beginning to suspect, I think.
DECKARD:?Suspect??How can it not know what it is?
The effect of those memories would seem to explain why Rachael was so much harder to identify; as Tyrell says, they give her much more experience with emotions (even if that experience is second-hand), and so her reactions to emotion-provoking questions are likely to be very different, and much more human-like, than those of replicants such as Leon who don't have them.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.