Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins?

Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins? - Batman Logo

And if the fire didn't kill anyone, what would be the point? Destroying a headquarters won't prevent the organisation carrying out its plan.



Best Answer

Besides the fact that, as oers said, he wasn't Batman at that time (and has maybe not thought that philosophically about killing people yet), the only reasons for doing this are not just to either kill anyone or destroy the organization.

The most obvious reason for starting the fire was to make distraction and chaos, which enables him to escape. I would say he was at a dead end and needed some way to get out of it fast, so starting the fire was a good chance for enabling his escape. He probably didn't think through that fast if anyone would get killed in this fire, he just needed to escape. He didn't kill anyone on purpose there.




Pictures about "Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins?"

Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins? - Black Android Smartphone
Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins? - Woman Holding Black Batman Fidget Spinner
Did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins? - Woman in White and Red Long-sleeved Shirt



Did Batman break his no kill rule?

During the confrontation with Two-Face, Batman tackles the District Attorney off a ledge to save Gordon's son, causing him to fall to his death. This was likely done because he saw no other way of saving the child, forcing him to break the "No Killing" rule.

Did Batman break his one rule in Batman Begins?

In the First movie, Batman doesn't break his rule. He explains: "I won't kill you, but that doesn't mean I have to save you." He didn't, technically, kill him. The Dark Knight, however, is a different matter. Yes, in this film, he does break his rule.

How many times has Batman broke his no killing rule?

Historically, Batman has maintained his strict "no kill" policy to the letter.

When did Batman get his no kill rule?

The Origin of Batman's \u201cNo Killing\u201d Rule The first issue (we could find) where Batman states that he never kills is Batman #4, which was released as the series' "Winter Issue" in January 1941.



Everything Wrong With The Dark Knight In 4 Minutes Or Less




More answers regarding did Batman break his no killing rule when he burned down the monastery in Batman Begins?

Answer 2

I believe that the definitive answer is no, he did not break his code about not killing people, the reason being is that he didn’t intentionally kill them with his bare hands. As we see near the end of Batman Begins, he has no problem with letting Ra’s Al Ghul and his clan die in the crash. He even stated

"I'm not going to kill you, but I don’t have to save you."

So this brings us back to him blowing up that building. He didn’t intend for any prisoners to be killed, he was just trying to escape. Since he didn’t directly kill them, it doesn’t break his code.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Henry & Co., Thorn Yang, EVG Kowalievska, EVG Kowalievska