How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all?

How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all? - Two Alien Inside Car Wallpaper

In Arrival, how does Louise begin to understand the aliens? There is absolutely no frame of reference or any common vocabulary between the languages.

How does Louise/translators decode a bunch of random symbols that are new to them?

Also, throughout the movie, the translators were looking for patterns to decode the language. But how could they do that for they wouldn't have seen such a pattern earlier. What were they comparing the patterns to?



Best Answer

First of all, let us remember that this is a movie, and not a documentary. As Jessica Coon puts it,

If they’d done justice to all that goes into understanding an unknown language, you’d just be watching a series of TED talks.

You mention that there is no common frame of reference, but you are forgetting something. Movements and reality are common to us all. If I point or show or somehow indicate to you any random object and I pronounce its name enough times, you will eventually associate the object to the sound.

Louise essentially tries to establish connections between sounds and letters against objects and actions.

From the LA Times,

The professor said that [that approach] would essentially be the approach field workers take too.

She shows them words and reads them out loud for the aliens to learn how one related to the other (tbh, my own opinion is that they knew english all along, but that's is off-topic). Then she points to what the words actually mean (herself and Ian, for example).

From Slate,

In a way, she proceeded the way a linguist would proceed in doing field research. Get very basic concepts, get the person to understand that we want to get individual words. You’ll usually start with things like body parts—okay, point to your arm, what’s their word for arm—and you build up from there. And she did that.

The aliens did the same as she asked them questions. The idea was to get them to give answers with similar words, meanings, links, and pick up on the patterns of what they meant. However, the entire process is not shown (on the film at least, I'm not sure about the book).

From Slate (once more),

I would have preferred if they spent a little more time on the early aspects of her working on the language. Once she had these splotches, they jumped pretty quickly from “OK, that’s how they communicate a concept” to “I’ve now got a mini-dictionary of a bunch of concepts,” right? They show you some cryptic images of her making measurements of different chunks of the splotches. But they don’t really show the process of how she got from there to understand what chunks mean what.




Pictures about "How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all?"

How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all? - Abstract background with white glassy drops
How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all? - Black female barista together with colleague using laptop at work
How does Louise even begin to understand aliens at all? - Closeup top view of plain wet abstract surface with small dripped water drops of different shapes placed on white background



What did Louise tell Shang in Arrival?

Louise tells Shang that his wife spoke to her in a dream and told her that \u201cwar doesn't make winners, only widows.\u201d Ian tells her that she can't stop what's happening. She responds by telling him that she just did.

What did Louise tell the Chinese general?

Louise then persuades Shang to call off his attack in the \u201cpresent\u201d by telling him what his wife's dying words were and thus proving to him that the aliens' language has taught her how to time-travel.

Is Heptapod a real language?

Heptapod is a Language \u2013 So Do You Translate it or Interpret it? To use the Heptapod language, particularly the written form known as Heptapod B, is to know the consequential (and seemingly inevitable) end result of your thought before you write or say anything.

Why does Louise have Hannah?

It's our ability to choose what we want to do: good or bad. In Louise's case, she chose to have Hannah even when she knew that her daughter was going to die at a very young age. Can fate and free will coexist?



Lue Elizondo Λ Sean Cahill on UFOs, Consciousness, Time, the Difficulty Talking about the Phenomenon




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Miriam Espacio, Karolina Grabowska, Ketut Subiyanto, Karolina Grabowska