What is bad about the Dent Act?

What is bad about the Dent Act? - Uneven surface of light white color

From this answer about The Dark Knight Rises:

John Blake to Gordon: Those men locked up for eight years in Blackgate, and denied parole under the Dent Act, based on a lie?

As the answer explains,

The Dent Act. among all things puts dangerous and important cogs of the organised crime world into prison with no possibility of parole. So essentially they are not gonna see the light of the day till a long long time and deter people from being involved in such activities.

Is it bad, to put cogs in organised crime and put such people in prison for 8 years and deter them from such activities? What he complain about?

Perhaps they put them in prison with no real evidence?

If so, why didn't they do that earlier? What allowed them to it and how is Dent related to this?

Are they sure they actually did anything bad?



Best Answer

Perhaps they put them in prison with no real evidence?

No, they were properly convicted (it seems).

What the Dent Act did was deny those properly convicted early parole meaning they had to serve their full sentences (sometimes up to 20 years).

What he complain about?

What he is complaining about is that Harvey Dent was a murderer and so "justice" in his name is not appropriate.

As your link in the question states in the primary answer (What is the Dent act and how it could possibly work out?):

After 18 months of jail time, according to the mayor, the men would try to appeal by using any dirt about Harvey. But since Batman took the fall for Dent, there wasn't any dirt to be found so the criminals were locked up still.




Pictures about "What is bad about the Dent Act?"

What is bad about the Dent Act? - Man in Blue and White Floral Long Sleeve Shirt
What is bad about the Dent Act? - Young troubled woman using laptop at home
What is bad about the Dent Act? - Unrecognizable young woman demonstrating prohibition sign showing gesture of refuse using hand and note with sign stop



What did the Dent Act do?

The Dent Act was a law that was passed after the death of Harvey Dent. It was a law that was so effective that it wiped out organized crime by locking up all 1000 criminals in Gotham City for eight years after the Joker's reign of terror upon Gotham City as well as the death of Dent himself.

What did Harvey Dent do in The Dark Knight Returns?

Harvey turned back to crime, he hired a gang to rob a bank and then planned on blowing up the Gotham Life Building. He aired a broadcast demanding a ransom, his face wrapped in bandages. His actual plan was to be on the tower when it blew up and killing himself.

Does Gordon tell the truth about Harvey Dent?

Bane's Backstory When Bruce is thrown in the same pit Talia grew up in, he learns of Ra's al Ghul's child that escaped the underground prison. It's assumed by both Bruce and audience that the child was Bane. But in the flashback scene, the child who escaped is not wearing a mask.



\




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Monstera, Alex Koch, Andrea Piacquadio, Anete Lusina