Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate]

Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate] - Person Holding Blue Berries on White Ceramic Bowl

In the Kill Bill movie franchise, Hattori Hanzo breaks his 28 year old oath and makes the best sword in his life for Beatrice Kiddo.

There was no indication in the movies that Hanzo knew Bill. Then why did he break his oath and help Beatrice Kiddo just when she told him that she wanted to kill Bill?

What's the specialty about her that makes Hanzo help her?

Best Answer

Bill was Hattori Hanzo's former student. He used Hanzo's teachings for dishonorable purposes, causing Hanzo to retire.

But when Beatrix shows that she has the resolve to defeat Bill, Hanzo feels honorbound to make her a sword so she'd have a chance at winning.

From ZacPensol at reddit

Considering that everyone seemed to make a big deal out of Beatrix having a Hanzo sword, and the emphasis put on Budd having one, I don't think that the rest of the team had them.

Beatrix refers to Bill as a former pupil of Hanzo's, and Hanzo knows exactly who she's referring to. I always figured that Bill studied swordplay under Hanzo in a similar way that he studied martial arts from Pai Mei. However, Hanzo was perhaps put off by Bill's darker tendencies because Bill saw the swordsmanship as a means of creating violence instead of ending it.

So whatever happened and Bill quit being Hanzo's apprentice and went on to form the DiVAS. Hanzo is a guy with connections most-certainly. I'm sure it's no stretch of the imagination that he eventually heard about - or even kept tabs on - Bill and how he'd become the leader of such a notorious assassination squad. His shame at having aided in creating not only weapons that kill people, but "creating" Bill as a deadly individual, lead him to retire in guilt so as not to ever create something or someone as horrible as Bill again.

He, of course, breaks this oath when Beatrix shows up because, though he's hesitant to create another great sword that could so easily kill more people, in Beatrix he not only sees a lightness that was not in Bill, but a way to secure his heart and mind that the evil he'd helped create "Bill" would be brought to an end. Perhaps this wouldn't wipe free his guilt over Bill's former actions, but it would at least ease his mind to know that Bill's reign of terror was over.

Pictures about "Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate]"

Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate] - Black and Silver Motorcycle Engine
Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate] - Motorcyclists Taking Break by Road
Why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate] - Girl in White Crew Neck T-shirt Sitting on White Plastic Chair

What happened between Bill and Hattori Hanzo?

In Kill Bill Vol. 1, Hattori Hanzo breaks a blood oath in order to make the sword for Beatrix, specifically so she can kill Bill with it. Then, In vol. 2, Bud and Bill are talking about Hanzo breaking the oath; bud says "Them Japs sure know how to hold a grudge."

Was the sword in Pulp Fiction a Hattori Hanzo?

(Headcanon) The sword in pulp fiction is a Hattori Hanzo sword.

How much does Hattori cost?

HattoriDetailsGender:FemaleBot Name:BottoriStore Price:2,3008 more rows

The Hattori Hanzo Paradox

More answers regarding why did Hattori Hanzo break his oath? [duplicate]

Answer 2

In the scene where The Bride is trying to get Hattari Hanzo to make her a sword she mentions a "former" pupil and he changes his mind, writing on the window Bill,which shows that Bill was a former student of Hattori Hanzo.

So Hattori hanzo knew Bill. Bill used Hattari Hanzo's teachings for evil, instead of belief and self defense.So Mr.Hanzo decided to make the sword for Beatrice.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA, Emeric Laperriere, Thien An, Antonius Ferret