Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events?

Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events? - Group of People on Event

In Harry Potter : Goblet of fire, There are three thrilling events that chosen wizards from each school (pretty sure it was four from each school and there are I think two other schools other than Hogwarts) had to compete in these events. Here are the events:

  1. Wizard/witch must try to sieze the golden egg from an arena while being chased and hunted by a type of dragon, possibly without dying.
  2. The competitor must rescue students at the bottom of a lake using a special seaweed that aids the breathing of someone under water, the enemy in this are mermaids.
  3. The competitors much enter a maze and get out via portkey, this was a deadly one as take the wrong turn and possible trapping happens, but this went horribly wrong as two competitors (Harry and Frederick) went to a dummy port key after trying to out run closing maze channel which took them straight to Voldemort and Frederick was killed by Voldemort's curse.

Only one of these events was worth watching, and it was the Dragon. The other two, the spectators were either staring for hours at a lake surface waiting for something to happen and waiting for someone to arrive out of the maze.

Why didn't the school come up with a way for the spectators to actually see what was going on in the other two events, as it is meant to be magical?



Best Answer

tl;dr: Since the story is viewed from Harry's point of view, we follow him as a participator and don't get shown (in either book or movie) how the spectators, for whom stands were built at each location, observe the proceedings, but it is presumably via magical means.

This is going to be a tough one:

The Tournament, called the Triwizard is held (for the first time in over a century) at Hogwarts during the protagonist's (Harry's) fourth school year.

It is called Triwizard because there are three trials, and because three (a trio of) schools compete in it. Each school sends one contestant, to be selected by the eponomous Goblet of Fire. Due to machinations by the bad guys Harry gets selected as competitor, called champions as well.

As to the tasks:

During the second one, it is not students that are tied to the lake, but people that are personally close to the champions. Since it is happening at a school the hostages turn out to be students, yes, three of them are even students from Hogwarts Harry knows and cares about: his best friends Ron (his own hostage) and Hermione and the girl he has a crush on (Cho). But the fourth one is Fleur's little sister Gabrielle (why she is there the whole time (she arrived with the rest of the Beauxbatons girls) eludes me, since she should be 8 years old). And only Harry uses gillyweed, the others use other methods of underwater operation (shark transfiguration, bubblehead charm); it's at the champion's discretion.

During the third one, the cup in the middle that teleported them (Harry and Cedric) away was not supposed to do that, again due to machinations by the bad guys. It was not supposed to be a portkey at all.

In both the book and the movie (the latter being the topic of the question) we follow Harry's story. We actually don't see (in either medium, because Harry doesn't watch the tournament, he is a part of it), how the spectators (for whom they built stands after all) observe the event.

It could very well be via magical means. The book version might contradict this, because Professor Dumbledore converses with the chieftainess of the merpeople in the lake after the task, but then again, that could be just for clarification as to the reason why Harry didn't leave with Ron once he got there, but waited for all hostages to be rescued (In the movie the merpeople are actively hostile and not just playfully so, as they are in the book, so Dumbledore doesn't talk to her).




Pictures about "Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events?"

Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events? - Soccer Stadium
Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events? - Woman and Young Boy Sitting on Floor with Laptop
Why didn't Hogwarts come up with a better way for spectators to watch the other two events? - Two Lesbian Women Standing Face to Face and Looking at Each Other with Affection



What is the biggest plot hole in Harry Potter?

Harry Potter: 15 Plot Holes That Make No Sense (Even If You've Read The Books)
  • 9 Using Multiple Wands.
  • 10 The Magic Behind Thestrals. ...
  • 11 Why Didn't The Ministry Use Veritaserum? ...
  • 12 Harry, Hermione and Ron's Food Crisis. ...
  • 13 Peter Pettigrew And The Marauders Map. ...
  • 14 How Functional Is The Trace? ...
  • 15 The Painting Inconsistency. ...


Why did Goblet of Fire choose Harry?

Barty used a powerful Confundus Charm to confuse the Goblet of Fire so that it would select Harry's name as the fourth contestant from an unspecified school. The plan worked since Harry followed through the competition against Cedric Diggory, Fleur Delacour, and Viktor Krum.

Why did the cup take Harry and Cedric?

Cedric got to the cup first because Harry helped him out of two tight jams.



Why Didn't You Stop Me?




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: anna-m. w., Pixabay, Ivan Samkov, RODNAE Productions