Why does Mal insist on communal suicide?

Why does Mal insist on communal suicide? - Woman in Blue Crew Neck T-shirt Sitting on Black Chair

Why does Mal insist on communal suicide in Inception? If they were really still dreaming, she could just die alone and kick Cobb on the level above (if death would wake them up, it means there are no synchronized kicks needed). Murder-suicide would be another option. From her point of view, this would amount to helping a deluded person and her solo suicide as negligence.

Of course, she ends up committing solo suicide, but before that, she first spent weeks/month (?) trying to persuade Cobb and then executed an elaborate scheme that involved having three psychiatrists declare her sane and wrecking a hotel room. The alternatives would have been much easier. Her instinctual resistance to killing her husband would probably have been weakened, because she already did it multiple times during their boundless dream-exploration.

In my view, her focus on communal suicide points more to mental illness as opposed to actually believing they need to wake up.


Best Answer

You can't wake somebody up from Limbo with a kick.

The movie makes it clear that, for a kick to work, you need to be able to sense it in the next level down. In Limbo, you have no sense of what is happening in the levels above at all - you are completely removed. You can't simply kick somebody out of Limbo because they can't sense it at all - you have to follow them in.

I have no explanation for why she didn't think to kill Cobb and then kill herself, though.




Pictures about "Why does Mal insist on communal suicide?"

Why does Mal insist on communal suicide? - Students Sitting Inside the Classroom While Using Their Smartphone
Why does Mal insist on communal suicide? - Boy Sitting on His Desk While Reading His Book
Why does Mal insist on communal suicide? - Students Sitting Inside the Classroom While Using Their Smartphone



How is suicide represented in Hamlet?

After his mother's wedding, Hamlet wants nothing more than just to die, but to commit suicide is a sin in the eyes of God. Thus, by committing suicide he would simply be damning himself to hell, which will also cause pain and suffering. Leading Hamlet to dismiss the thought and prolong his suffering.

What does existentialism say about suicide?

Many forms of existentialist thinking essentially begin with the premise that life is objectively meaningless, and proceed to the question of why one should not just kill oneself; they then answer this question by suggesting that the individual has the power to give personal meaning to life.

Who all committed suicide in Hamlet?

Hamlet and Ophelia are the two characters in Hamlet who are involved with suicide, although Hamlet only contemplates it, but Ophelia actually commits suicide in Act 4. Throughout the novel, the act of suicide is treat religiously, morally and aesthetically.

What is the difference between suicidal ideation and suicidal intent?

Suicidal ideation is any self-reported thoughts of engaging in suicide-related behavior. Subtypes of suicide-related ideations depend on the presence or absence of suicidal intent. To have suicidal intent is to have suicide or deliberate self-killing as one's purpose.



Jonestown Mass Suicide: Revisiting The Cult That Ended With The Deaths Of 900 | TODAY




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: cottonbro, RODNAE Productions, RODNAE Productions, RODNAE Productions