Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant?

Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant? - Woman Wearing Gray Shirt Holding Head

In the beginning of the Alien: Covenant movie, a group of colonists from the main ship make a landing on an unknown planet, which they found out accidentally after ship has been bombarded by an unknown wave from a star collapse and what bothers me, is that they don't wear any spacesuits, any protective gear, any air filter systems, just nothing.

Is that really the way future space expeditions gonna explore new possible planets presumed as possible habitable homes for humanity?

Every 5th grader knows, from the biology school lessons, that water, air, and even earth itself contains and gives life to a thousands of viruses, bacteria, and microorganisms.

You can breathe in bacteria, or virus, and be dead in a seconds.

Do film makers really suppose we will take it as realistic depiction of extraterrestrial expedition?

Reality check just screams out loud.

What do you think can be their motivation for such a decision?



Best Answer

In a comparative manner of speaking, when we look back at the expedition team in Prometheus, they removed their helmets as soon as they found the air to be breathable, without explicitly screening for pathogens.

Ford: Jesus. The sunlight is heating the water. Check out the humidity.

Charlie: Yeah, look at the CO2 levels. Outside it's completely toxic, and in here there's nothing. It's breathable.

Elizabeth: What are you doing? Charlie don't be an idiot.

Charlie: Hey don't be a skeptic. Right, there's something generating an atmosphere. David?

David: Dr. Holloway is correct.

Ford: Cleaner than Earth actually.

Charlie: They were terraforming here.

Elizabeth: Please don't do...

Charlie: I'm not wearing this thing anymore.

If this is how experts act like in the new Alien universe, a civilian team is naturally less prudent with safety.

However, Ford (the medic) did use the phrase "cleaner than Earth", and Charlie did check his instruments before removing his helmet. So giving them the benefit of doubt, we may assume their instruments screen for toxins and pathogens automatically, in addition to atmospheric composition.


Fast-forward to Alien: Covenant.

Soon after they arrived at the planet:

Ricks: Tox level within tolerances.

Right after they have landed:

Mother: Confirming atmospheric composition. Oxygen 19.5%. Nitrogen 79.4%. Barometric pressure 15.4 Psi.

And... they opened the door.

That's pretty much it.

But in "Prologue: Last Supper" when the crew was toasting before cryo, Daniels mentioned that Covenant was the first ever large-scale colonization mission to come this far into our galaxy. This implied that there were likely to be smaller scale colonization missions previously, since a moment earlier Rosenthal said:

I heard about these crazy bugs just outside this colonial post. Apparently they look like cockroaches the size of a giant poodle.

So humanity have encountered alien life before. Thus it is safe to assume that they are aware of alien pathogens and there are protocols in place to deal with alien lifeforms. For instance, there is a Med Bay in the Lander and there are quarantine protocols to handle such infections... after they've been exposed, instead of prevention. After all, chances that alien pathogens being compatible with human physiology, are slim.


Aside from in-universe explanations, removing helmets is an often-used artistic license just like doctors not wearing masks in films, to let the audience better see the face of the characters. Alien: Covenant is a survival horror movie, a science fiction, but not science documentary. Try not to pay too much attention to these things and enjoy the movie!




Pictures about "Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant?"

Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant? - Woman Wearing White T-shirt and Blue Denim Bottoms
Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant? - Assorted Clothes
Why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant? - Men's White Shirt



Is the xenomorph in Alien: Covenant?

In the build-up to last year's Alien: Covenant, Ridley Scott made a candid admission: he had refused to put the xenomorph in 2012's Prometheus because he thought the creature had its day and needed to be left to the past.

Is the planet in Alien: Covenant lv426?

In Alien, LV-426 is the planet where the crew of the Nostromo first found the alien eggs that eventually gave birth to a xenomorph. The crew follows what they believe to be a distress call to LV-426 where they discover a massive ship of unknown origin.

What are the embryos in Alien: Covenant?

In the film the Covenant was a colony ship sent into deep space to found a human colony on an alien world. The ship's stores included many materials necessary to establish the colony. Among these materials were frozen human embryos that would be used to help populate the colony once it was established.

What was the point of Alien: Covenant?

Around the midway point of Alien: Covenant, viewers discover that the overpowered android David (one of two robot characters played to creepy perfection by MVP Michael Fassbender) wants to turn the already-deadly Xenomorphs into perfect killing machines so he can unleash hell on the galaxy.



WHY DON'T WE - HOW DO YOU LOVE SOMEBODY




More answers regarding why don't the colonists wear spacesuits in Alien: Covenant?

Answer 2

Suspension of disbelief.

Simply put, it is called suspension of disbelief, where one is expected

to suspend one's critical faculties and believe the unbelievable; sacrifice of realism and logic for the sake of enjoyment.

In-universe, you can claim that their equipment could scan for pathogens, bacteria, virus, but those need not be permanently present to be dangerous. They could get triggered (as they did in the film), they can have a life cycle (be nocturnal, for example), they can move around (carried by wind).

Logically, it is an insanely stupid idea to remove protective gear in unknown environments. However, if we could hardly see their expressions throughout the whole movie due to them having helmets, we wouldn't appreciate their acting so much. Also, the plot would have to be quite different as well (no early on-set attacks to drive the plot forward!).

Answer 3

Here is a simple answer:

Actors can have clear domed helmets to allow viewers to see their acting. Sharp objects can tear a space suit or the aliens can tear or use acid to penetrate a suit. No reason to make the protagonists into idiots just to get them infected.

Once one is infected they would have a quarantine procedure that they would have to follow and not be like hey we are in a hurry lets all get infected. Once again a good writer would come up with a plot device to have the infection overcome their quarantine.

Sadly most Hollywood pictures pay little attention to their writers and end up letting directors run mayhem with the plot just because they are focused on their visuals and not on a believable plot.

Answer 4

I disagree with people saying "if they had helmets on we couldn't see the actors faces". I recently re-watched "The Martian". In that movie they had helmets on at ALL times when outside of a habitat or vehicle. All they did was make it a big glass dome with lights inside to see the actors faces. In reality there was no helmet, it was added in during post-production so there were no reflections of green screens and camera crews.

Of course there is some suspension of disbelief. For me that is ignoring the fact that intergalactic space travel to an alien planet with black alien spores on it is happening 80 years from now.

A short dialogue about scanning the air and then agreeing it's safe to not wear a helmet would of been enough for me. To not even include that shows a disrespect for the audiences intelligence and lazy writing.

It's hard to ignore the big things if the little things aren't believable.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Spencer Selover, Chelsi Peter, Kai Pilger, Spencer Selover