Has anybody ever invented a rationale for the quick-draw duel of western films?
To be clear, I'll describe what I mean by quick-draw duel. Two lone gunslingers stand facing one another in an abandoned street with no obstacles between them. They eye each other, hands poised above their holsters. At some point, both of them draw their pistols and fire until one of them is struck fatally. It's well-known that gunfights weren't really so fair or planned, since people generally wanted to survive above all else.
However, even assuming that characters in western films had this fictional honor that compelled them to fight on even terms, the quick-draw duel doesn't seem logical. There's no referee indicating when to draw their guns, so they either draw at a specific time for no reason, or one man draws first after an inexplicable amount of time staring, and the other has to draw quicker to shoot first. Has anyone during the heyday of the western ever attempted to explain the logic?
Best Answer
The fast draw in films was inspired by some real life accounts
The object of fast draw as a combative sport is to quickly draw one's pistol and fire with the most accuracy. The sport has been inspired by accounts of duels and gunfights which incorporated it during the Wild West, such as the Wild Bill Hickok – Davis Tutt duel, Luke Short-Jim Courtright Duel, Gunfight at the OK Corral, Long Branch Saloon Shootout and others, which in turn inspired the gunfights seen in Hollywood western movies.
Apparently they’re the ‘wild west’ crude form of the classical sword duel we know from Europe and the past. As cited in Agnew, Jeremy. December 2, 2014. The Creation of the Cowboy Hero: Fiction, Film and Fact, p. 88.
According to this, the ‘fast draw’ is nothing more than two pissed off people who have pistols and will react at the slightest provocation, in turn giving us this sort of instant reaction. There wasn’t necessarily any sort of ‘honour’ or rules dictated as might be seen in films, which are highly romanticized.
In the end it was nothing more than a dangerous game of chicken and testosterone.
Pictures about "Has anybody ever invented a rationale for the quick-draw duel of western films?"
Did quick draw duels actually happen?
If we're talking about a quick-draw duel, like the ones in movie westerns, it almost never happened. The Hickok case is famous precisely because it was so rare.Who invented the fast draw?
One can't speak of fast draw shooting without mentioning Arvo Ojala.Is quick draw real?
Fast draw, also known as quick draw, is the ability to quickly draw a handgun and accurately fire it upon a target in the process. This skill was made popular by romanticized depictions of gunslingers in the Western genre, which in turn were inspired by famous historical gunfights in the American Old West.Who draws first in a western duel?
In Western films, the gunslinger that draws first always gets shot. This seems like a standard Hollywood trope but it diverted the attention of no less a scientist that Niels Bohr, one of history's greatest physicists.My name is nobody - Terence Hill Epic Fight
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Sami Abdullah, Sami Abdullah, Sami Abdullah, Artem Podrez