How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island?

How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island? - Ancient sculpture of holy warrior in park

Captain Jack Sparrow stole a crown from Isla de Muerta and wasn't cursed. If he was immortal why did Will have to save him when they try to hang Captain Jack for his crimes? Why isn't he cursed when he stole that crown?



Best Answer

I assume that you're asking about the final scenes on the island, when Jack is rummaging through the riches in the island's cave (providing a very unromantic setting for Will's and Elizabeth's conversation)

The answer to your question is that not all the items in that cave bring you the curse. Only the coins do, as explained to Elizabeth by captain Barbossa:

You don't know what this is, do you?
It's a pirate medallion. This is Aztec gold. One of 882 identical pieces they delivered in a stone chest to Cortes himself. Blood money paid to stem the slaughter he wreaked upon them with his armies.
But the greed of Cortes was insatiable. So, the heathen gods placed upon the gold a terrible curse. Any mortal that removes but a single piece from that stone chest shall be punished for eternity.




Pictures about "How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island?"

How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island? - Textile Australian flag with crumples
How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island? - Top view of whole fresh pineapples with green leaves and brown skin arranged on yellow background in modern light studio
How could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island? - Arrangement of ripe pineapples in studio



How did Captain Jack Sparrow die?

Realizing Sparrow is the target, Elizabeth traps him aboard the Black Pearl as the crew abandons the ship, and kisses him while she handcuffs him to the mast. Then, the monster devours Sparrow and drags the ship and his soul to Davy Jones's Locker.

Why does Captain Jack Sparrow have a sore on his face?

In the Pirates of the Caribbean series (2003), Jack Sparrow has a red spot on this jaw. This red spot is a joke between Depp and the makeup department. The red spot is actually supposed to be syphilis, and it gets progressively more noticeable in each film.

Was Jack Sparrow cursed the whole time?

Show activity on this post. Jack was not cursed, to begin with, but once he persuaded Barbossa to ally himself and not kill Will, he picked up 4 coins and threw back 3 to dramatically say "every" (throws down coin) "last" (throws down coin) "One" (throws down coin).

Who is the real captain of the Black Pearl?

The true edgy bad boy deserving of attention, and the command of the Black Pearl, was Captain Hector Barbossa. Along with Jack Sparrow and Jack's friend and first mate, Joshamee Gibbs, Barbossa is one of only three main characters to appear in all five Pirates movies.



Film Theory: Jack Sparrow is Dying... Of THIRST!




More answers regarding how could Captain Jack Sparrow die if he stole a crown from the island?

Answer 2

To finish the answer: He stole the crown but he didn't keep the crown. At the end of the fight with Barbossa, while Barbossa is distracted looking at Will, Jack uses his sword to cut his own hand, spilling blood on the crown, then tosses the crown to Will, who drops it (and the one on the chain) back into the chest. At that point, the curse lifts. So when the hanging attempt occurs, Jack is mortal again.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Csongor Kemény, vectors icon, SHVETS production, SHVETS production