Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out?

Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out? - Black and White Stars during Night Time

The first Cosmos, narrated and co-written by Carl Sagan came out in 1980. But since then, there have been numerous achievements in Science; many things have changed and in 2014, Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey came out, which was more up to date than the last one.

As a person who is interested in watching the show(s), should I watch both of them, or is the first one outdated by the second one?



Best Answer

No: Cosmos (1980) is not obsolete.

This is obviously a very subjective topic, but I'd argue you could (and should!) watch both series.

Firstly, Carl Sagan. The man was simply amazing, with one of the most mesmeric voices imaginable. Watch at least one episode, just to hear it.

Secondly, a lot of the science in the original Cosmos still holds true today. For the parts that don't, the latest editions of the DVDs have added scenes at the end of the episode where Sagan explains how the science has changed since this episode.

Obviously, there are some noticeable changes, such as Pluto no longer being a planet, but largely the fundamental things he covers, such as the age of the universe, the Cosmic Calendar, the achievements of the likes of Tycho Brahe and Joannes Kepler, global warming, the big bang - our understanding of these things has not fundamentally shifted between 1980 and 2014 to an extent that what Saga was saying was incorrect.

Whilst the new series is fantastic, the majority of the changes are aesthetic. The newer animation means some of the historical tales, rather than just showing a presenter on screen narrating and gesticulating, actually show CGI created stories of what the narrator is covering.

In terms of the major differences, I would argue it heavily comes down to the oratory style you prefer.

Sagan had a captivating voice and challenged us to use our imaginations when considering all the evidence. Even when describing the vast size of space, he made it seem a little less scary with his hypnotic voice.

Tyson on the other hand has always had a much more impersonal, revealing oratory style. He addresses things in absolute detail, and is more provocative than Sagan. For example, whilst Sagan never went into detail on his own religious beliefs, Tyson is much more outspoken about his feelings that science should influence politics.

Ultimately, I'd suggest watching both. Start with Sagan's and take your time enjoying them. Then watch Tyson's and see the aesthetic differences (the first episode is very similar otherwise).




Pictures about "Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out?"

Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out? - White Cosmos Flowers in Close-up Photography
Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out? - Mountain Covered Snow Under Star
Is Cosmos (1980) obsolete now that Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey (2014) has come out? - Gray and Black Galaxy Wallpaper



In which order should I watch cosmos?

You can skip watching the personal voyage as it's outdated but then, you will miss out on being in the company of the host Carl Sagan, which is not a good decision at all. So, start with personal voyage, then spacetime Odyssey.

When was Cosmos?

The series was first broadcast by the Public Broadcasting Service in 1980, and was the most widely watched series in the history of American public television until The Civil War (1990)....Cosmos: A Personal VoyageOriginal networkPBSOriginal releaseSeptember 28 \u2013 December 21, 1980Chronology15 more rows

When was Carl Sagan Cosmos?

Cosmos is a 1980 popular science book by astronomer and Pulitzer Prize-winning author Carl Sagan. Its 13 illustrated chapters, corresponding to the 13 episodes of the Cosmos TV series, which the book was co-developed with and intended to complement, explore the mutual development of science and civilization.

Who did Cosmos?

Background. The original 13-part Cosmos: A Personal Voyage first aired in 1980 on the Public Broadcasting Service, and was hosted by Carl Sagan.



COSMOS A Spacetime Odyssey | Future Cosmic Calendar




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Joe, Sonny Sixteen, eberhard grossgasteiger, Pixabay