Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional?

Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional? - Woods Covered With Snow

enter image description here

Everyone knows about the legendary director Stanley Kubrick and how meticulous he was in taking his shots to perfection. This is the opening scene from the movie The Shining (1980). We see a shadow of the helicopter used for this continual shot during the opening credits. Was this mistake intentional on Kubrick's part? Because in the very same movie, he appointed an actual type writer to type the letters "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" and then recorded that typing sound to be used as background score. This background score was used during the zooming in scene of Jack Nicholson at his type writer.



Best Answer

It's a goof due to different aspect ratios of different media. The Helicopter shadow was not in the original theater release, only showing up when packaged for other media.

According to the pilot:

Due to Blyth's impaired sight lines, the camera operator concludes Kubrick “just liked those particular shots and didn't worry about the shadows.” He then added, “I have to say I was personally horrified to see the shadows on the first video release, since they'd never showed in the theatrical release, as we'd intended.”

This is similar to what people who watch Malcom in the Middle on Netflix experience, as the original aired in 4:3 televisión while being filmed in widescreen aspect ratios. When the HD release hit Netflix, you got to see more of the scene, including missing people, actor stand ins and other goofs.

Malcolm in the Middle example shot




Pictures about "Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional?"

Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional? - Forest
Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional? - Bokeh Photography of Different Colored Lights
Was the mistake in the opening scene of The Shining intentional? - Starry sky in dark night



Why are there so many mistakes in The Shining?

Various continuity errors all over The Shining have been pointed out over the years, and as Kubrick is famously known for being a perfectionist and paying extra attention to every single detail, it seems odd that The Shining has so many errors \u2013 but these were actually done on purpose to enhance the surrealism of being ...

How did they film the intro to The Shining?

Saint Mary Lake and Wild Goose Island in Glacier National Park, Montana was the filming location for the aerial shots of the opening scenes, with the Volkswagen Beetle driving along Going-to-the-Sun Road.

Why was Jack Torrance in the picture at the end of The Shining?

Stanley Kubrick said, \u201cThe ballroom photograph at the very end suggests the reincarnation of Jack.\u201d That means that Jack Torrance is the reincarnation of a guest or someone on staff at the Overlook in 1921.

What is the Wendy theory in The Shining?

Theory: The Shining's Events Are All In Wendy's Head The theory, created by Rob Navarro on YouTube, explains that most of the events in The Shining actually happen in Wendy's head as she goes into psychotic episodes.



Movie Mistakes: The Shining




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Mikhail Nilov, Oleksandr Pidvalnyi, Artem Beliaikin, Ave Calvar Martinez