Were Ninny and Idgie the same person?
In the movie Fried Green Tomatoes a story is told to an unhappy house wife about two women (Idgie and Ruth) and their adventures. The elderly woman telling the story is named Ninny Threadgoode. One of the principal characters is named Idgie Threadgoode. Are they the same person?
Best Answer
This is a fairly common misconception with the movie. In the book, Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe, it is absolutely clear that the two are separate characters. In fact, if I remember correctly, they are even in some of the same scenes. In the movie however, it is not as apparent. According to the film synopsis on Wikipedia, Ninny describes Idgie as her sister in law. Which would fit with the book, however I don't recall it ever being that specific in the movie. Another large part of the book that was played down in the film is the romantic relationship between Idgie and Ruth.
Pictures about "Were Ninny and Idgie the same person?"
Who is Ninny Threadgoode to Idgie Threadgoode?
Ninny married Idgie's older brother, Cleo. Idgie herself took off for Florida with another brother, Julian, where for decades she ran a roadside stand selling fruit and honey, and using her talents as a "bee charmer."Was Idgie the old lady?
The elderly woman telling the story is named Ninny Threadgoode. One of the principal characters is named Idgie Threadgoode.Were Idgie and Ruth lovers in Fried Green Tomatoes?
Although the movie has been criticized by gay groups for erasing the novel's implications of a sexual relationship between Idgie and Ruth, there is little in the book to be erased: the novel shows Idgie as a forthright suitor for Ruth's love, but only indirectly does it indicate that her love is not platonic.Who was Idgie at the end of Fried Green Tomatoes?
Ninny's most engaging tales involved the exploits of her free-spirited sister-in-law Idgie (Mary Stuart Masterson), who owned a small Alabama caf\xe9 in the 1920s, along with her best friend Ruth (Mary-Louise Parker).Fried Green Tomatoes | Idgie \u0026 Ruth Story ᴴᴰ
More answers regarding were Ninny and Idgie the same person?
Answer 2
The implication that Ninny and Idgie are the same person, therefore it is impossible based on several other points in the film.
The book makes it clear that Ninny and Idgie are different people.
Evelyn takes Ninny out of the nursing home to go live with her and they are visiting the cemetary when she finds the jar of honey and the note on Ruth's tombstone.
Answer 3
They are not the same person. Early in the movie Ninny tells Evelyn that she had married Idgie's brother, Cleo.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: SHVETS production, Quang Nguyen Vinh, Quang Nguyen Vinh, Quang Nguyen Vinh