Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate]

Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate] - TV set surrounded with figurines and souvenir of comic character and movie heroes

For example, take the Wolverine character.

Wolverine in comics look like this:

enter image description here

Whereas in movies he looks like this:

enter image description here

Why are the costumes not the same in the comics and their movie adaptations?



Best Answer

You're asking a question of why visual decisions were made when adapting and remediating a character. The most obvious if unhelpful answer is because someone chose to change it.

it kind of starts and ends there really; it was a choice, and questioning that choice can only be answered comprehensively by said person that chose to remove the costume.

The picture you include in you question is not actually Wolverine's most common costume (if we accept that the black stripes down the shoulders/across the chests is his 'classic' appearance), which just goes to show how many variations there are.

In the case of Wolverine, we can speculate quite confidently that this decision was made because, tonally, the costume wouldn't fit with the rest of the film. Cyclops' line 'What would you prefer? Yellow spandex?' is a direct reference to how absurd the costume would look compared to the leather costumes worn by the X-men in the film.

Lastly, whilst you may be correct in stating that Wolverine's yellow and blue costume is 'iconic', it's not his only costume, and it has changed several times over since his first appearance back in 1974. Below are just a handful of the changes that have been made to his appearance since that date.

First appearance: notice the black stripes across his chest

enter image description here

enter image description here

Variations range from subtle to extreme, but the point is there is no canonically accepted 'norm' for Wolverine's appearance.




Pictures about "Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate]"

Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate] - Woman in Yellow Long-sleeved Shirt
Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate] - Unrecognizable man using controller at home
Why are the costumes in comics and movie adaptations not the same? [duplicate] - Hipster man with collection of comic character



What is the most comic accurate suit?

10 Best Comics Accurate Costumes, Ranked
  • 5 Wanda Maximoff (WandaVision)
  • 6 Sandman (Spider-Man 3) ...
  • 7 John Walker US Agent (The Falcon and The Winter Soldier) ...
  • 8 Batman (Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice) ...
  • 9 Steve Rogers USO Suit (Captain America: The First Avenger) ...
  • 10 Scott Pilgrim (Scott Pilgrim vs. ...


What is comic adaptations?

Such adaptations tend to take three forms: The comic retells the story of the original work. The comic takes the characters and setting of the original, but tells a different series of stories. The comic continues where the original left off, or fills in the backstory.

Why do books have movie adaptations?

Adapting full-length novels, short stories or novellas to movies has become a very frequent endeavour. Filmmakers choose (potentially) iconic literary works and adapt them for the screen so that they become accessible to very large audiences, which is to be quite expected in the digital era.



The ONE Problem With Superhero Costumes




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Erik Mclean, Darya Sannikova, Erik Mclean, Erik Mclean