Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes?

Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes? - clothes on sale

A question regarding Once Upon a Time in the West. When Harmonica first met Jill in McBain's farm he tore off her clothes and his behavior looks very unpredictable.

Was the purpose that he did not want Jill to leave the farm?



Best Answer

Harmonica knew Frank's men would be observing from afar for the right moment to launch an assault. Tearing her clothes apart, sending her out, following her and then taking parts of his clothes off is to show vulnerability.

Frank's men were clearly surprised to see a man coming out of the farm, they had no idea who he was hence were cautious at first. The scene harmonica set up clearly worked as it lowered their guards getting g then to rush in.




Pictures about "Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes?"

Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes? - Red Product Tag
Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes? - Free stock photo of acoustic guitar, adult, bonfire
Why did Harmonica tear off Jill's clothes? - A Couple Sitting on Folding Chairs while Playing Musical Instruments



Why does Jill Mcbain sleep with Frank?

Jill might appear to represent the civilization, but she quickly adapts to this different moral code. She sleeps with Frank to save her life and sells the passion while maintaining her true goal of revenge at any cost.

Why does Harmonica help Frank?

Eventually, Harmonica's motive for revenge against Frank is revealed: When Harmonica was younger (a teenager), Frank forced him to keep his brother from men while he was hanging. After Harmonica collapsed with exhaustion, his brother was hanged.



C'era una volta il West - a scene with Jill and Harmonica




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Artem Beliaikin, Artem Beliaikin, Pavel Danilyuk, Pavel Danilyuk