Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses?

Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses? - Pink and White Love Print Textile

In the TV series Orphan Black, if all of the women played by Tatiana Maslany are portrayed as being clones, why does Cosima Niehaus need/wear glasses? Should they all be identical in this respect? Wouldn't they all have the same genetic makeup whether needing glasses or not? Were there clues given that the others have/wear contacts or something else going on?



Best Answer

Directly from the show's Twitter page:

OBTrivia: Cosima wears glasses, her clones don't. Her sight degenerated due to her individual environment &conditions. She studies too hard!

So it seems a fun way to separate her from all the other clones. Nothing more unfortunately.




Pictures about "Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses?"

Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses? - Wanted Lettering Text on Black Background
Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses? - Frowning African American girl near weathered concrete building with vandal graffiti and broken wall in poor district
Why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses? - High angle of crop person holding hands with ethnic boy stuck in dirty puddle in poor village





THE BEST OF: Cosima Niehaus




More answers regarding why does Cosima Niehaus need glasses?

Answer 2

You make two assumptions one of which is wrong in science and the other of which is wrong even within the show universe.

Firstly, short sightedness is not primarily genetically determined. There may be some influence but rates of short sightedness in the real world depend strongly on the childhood environment. People who spend most of their time outdoors are far less likely to be short-sighted. The cliché is true: geeks who spend time with books are far more likely to be short-sighted. So Cosima, being a book geek, is the short sighted one.

The other assumption is that the clones are identical. Clearly this is not true even within the show universe. They clearly differ in mental and physical health: some are mentally unstable and some are physically ill (at least two have apparent respiratory problems by the end of series one, though one of those dies early of a gunshot wound, but she is ill before this). At least one of them is capable of having children but we know several others appear to be infertile. They are also not strictly genetically identical as their DNA is, at the very least, stamped with a unique ID. And there are hints that Dr Leekie is studying them partially to discover what those health problems are.

In short, there is no logical problem with the short-sightedness either inside or outside the show universe.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Ann H, Anna Tarazevich, Julia Volk, Ahmed akacha