Why was Brenda Chapman released from directing "Brave"?
The title hopefully sums up the question entirely. Brenda Chapman was one of the lead animators on "Lion King" and was to be Pixar's debut female director on "Brave" which she has sole story credits on.
About a year or so into the process, Ms. Chapman was replaced by Mark Andrews and took a (temporary?) leave of absence from Pixar.
Most Googleable articles simply state the transition and do not address what may have been the motivation.
Has any of this information been released or is this issue going to be another of Hollywood's mysteries?
Best Answer
Unsurprisingly, the true details are hard to dig up, but this is nothing new. Pixar has a reputation for major shake-ups during production, see this extract from an article on hitfix.com:
They have the best track record in the business for a reason. They have a carefully managed story department, and they are ruthless during development. They have had several major shake-ups on films, including Cars, Ratatouille, and Toy Story 2, with directors being replaced and big chunks of story being thrown out.
A line from cartoonbrew.com, which first broke the news and continues to cover it, reads:
The key to their success is reworking and reworking a project until it becomes something great.
Looking through comments from Pixar workers who had seen the original animatic for The Bear and the Bow, it appears Chapman's intentions were a little more off the wall (for that read 'daring and interesting') and not a guaranteed sell for Pixar - hence the change of director and storyline (and title).
It must be said, though, that this move raised a lot of eyebrows and led to much furious internet debate, exemplified in an article from theWrap.com which includes the opening paragraph:
Pixar reaped a heap of anger Wednesday as the blogosphere accused Disney’s animation house of sexism -- and worse, being formulaic -- for firing Brenda Chapman, the first female director in its history, from “Brave,” a film she had written and nurtured through the development process.
Pictures about "Why was Brenda Chapman released from directing "Brave"?"
Why was Brenda Chapman removed from Brave?
In the midst of production, Pixar chief creative officer John Lasseter had removed Chapman from Brave over creative differences and replaced her with director Mark Andrews, a move that particularly smarted for many in the animation world because of the ground Chapman had broken \u2014 she was Pixar's first female director ...Did Brenda Chapman direct Brave?
In 1998, she became the first woman to direct an animated feature from a major studio, DreamWorks Animation's The Prince of Egypt. In 2012, she co-directed the Disney/Pixar film Brave with Mark Andrews and Steve Purcell, becoming the first woman to win the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature.Has Pixar had a female director?
With the release of the Disney movie \u201cTurning Red,\u201d Domee Shi is the first woman to solo-direct a Pixar film in the studio's 36-year history. Shi's work on the feature breaks a number of barriers in Hollywood.Is Brave an original story?
Announced in April 2008 as The Bear and the Bow, Brave is Pixar's first fairy tale. Writer and director Brenda Chapman considers it a fairy tale in the tradition of Hans Christian Andersen and the Brothers Grimm. She also drew inspiration from her relationship with her daughter.Director: Prince of Egypt, Pixar's Brave, Come Away ~ Brenda Chapman ~ Livecast #08
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Ann H, Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio