Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins?

Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins? - Crop black woman with trimmer preparing candles with wicks

In the beginning of the film Batman Begins after Bruce takes down the league of shadows' monastery, he saves Ducard's life and leaves him with one of the locals who says:

I will tell him you saved his life.

Later in the movie, when Ducard and the league show up at Wayne Manor, they set it on fire and leave Bruce for dead after Ducard says the following:

Justice is balance. You burned my house and left me for dead. Consider us even.

But Bruce did not leave him for dead. So is he just overlooking this detail to justify his actions? It seems out of character.



Best Answer

Ducard is actually Ra's Al Ghul. The "Ra's" that Bruce leaves for dead in the monastery when he burns it down is a decoy. So Bruce did try to kill Ra's and burned down his house, he just killed the wrong guy and the real Ra's came back for revenge.

Hence the line "You burned my house and left me for dead."




Pictures about "Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins?"

Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins? - Crop anonymous male with tattoo sawing piece of timber detail with planer in workshop
Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins? - Photo Of Crowd Of People Gathering Near Jama Masjid, Delhi
Did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins? - Pills on a Person's Hand



What happened Henri Ducard?

He boarded the monorail heading for Wayne Tower, but Batman boarded and subdued him. Batman then jammed the controls so the monorail couldn't stop, while James Gordon blew out a section of track. Batman refused to save Ra's al Ghul as he crashed to his death, along with the microwave emitter.

Why does Ducard destroy Gotham?

He explained that the destruction of Gotham was merely another mission by the League to correct humanity's recurring fits of decadence. Ra's then had his henchmen burn down the manor as a falling log knocked Bruce unconscious. Ra's stated that, "Justice is balance. You burned my house and left me for dead.

Why did Henri Ducard train Batman?

The Dark Knight in-training had tracked down Ducard, seeking to learn from him. Taking Wayne under his wing, Ducard taught him everything about tracking and trained Wayne to become a manhunter. Naturally, the two parted ways when Bruce found out that Ducard killed his targets.



Batman Begins Wayne Manor english




More answers regarding did Ducard make a mistake or willingly overlook this detail in Batman Begins?

Answer 2

Karan Shishoo's answer is almost certainly correct (Bruce tried to kill Ra's, and only mistaken identity caused him to drag Liam Neeson's character to safety. Had he known who Ra's really was, he would not have done so), but there is an important element of the movie that that answer leaves out: the difference between personal identity and symbolic identity. Batman as a symbol and an idea, more than as a specific person, is referenced frequently in the film.

Bruce's aim in burning down the monastery was primarily to break the League of Shadows, with which he had come to disagree. Whether or not he wanted Liam Neeson's character dead, he certainly wanted Ra's al Ghul, the purportedly immortal leader and director of that organization, to be finished. That Ra's true identity was hidden behind a dupe strongly parallels Bruce's own dual identity as Bruce Wayne and Batman.

Ra's may or may not have cared much if Bruce Wayne lived or died. But he cared very much about whether or not Batman lived or died, because Batman was directly opposing his efforts. Ra's tried to leave Batman to die in the fire, and had identified the correct person "under the mask" to target for that. He wanted to kill the symbol that Bruce had made Batman into, because Bruce was using that symbol to keep Gotham together while Ra's and the League were trying to destroy it.

That is pretty symmetrical to Bruce's actions: he tried to leave Ra's to die in a fire. But Ra's' mask was more effective than Bruce's, so the result was that some guy died but the symbol of Ra's al Ghul did not. Consequently the League's plans for Gotham continued, despite setbacks.

Answer 3

Emotion is a complicated thing.

Sure, Bruce saved Ducard, and left him in care so that he could continue to survive.

Bruce was clearly hoping that this information would be enough for Ducard to be okay with all of this.

Unfortunately, despite Bruce's best efforts, he was not. Bruce had burned down the house, and apparently the literal act of saving his life was not enough to leave Ducard with the feeling that Bruce had just dumped him on somebody else's doorstep and left him alone to get on with whatever little pieces were left of his life. In Ducard's defence, that's exactly what happened.

This feeling then spurred a vendetta of revenge. It's not far-fetched.

So it's not literal, but it's pretty close.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Anna Shvets, Ono Kosuki, Chattrapal (Shitij) Singh, Yaroslav Shuraev