Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins?

Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins? - Beginning of construction project in industrial zone

Before the final test during the training of Bruce, Ra's Al Ghul gives him a bowl containing blue flower and some other things to smell in.

enter image description here

After that, Bruce faces his fears such as bats and death of his parents. But here he is able to control himself and fight.

However, when Dr. Crane releases the toxin, Bruce wasn't able to control his fear and got knocked out for two days.

Later, Ra's Al Ghul reveals that the toxin was made out of that blue flower and it appeared that Bruce had the same effect both times.

So, why Bruce was able to control his fear during training, but not when Dr. Crane attacks? Is there something more in the toxin?



Best Answer

I don't think this is ever explained in the movie directly but I would suggest this is a matter of concentration

Not Bruce's concentration but rather the concentrated liquid which makes the Fear Gas/Toxin.

Bruce actually says..

I’ve felt those effects before...but this was much more potent

and

It’s some kind of weaponized hallucinogen. Administered in aerosol form.

Yes, we know that the blue flower is involved in the process of making the Toxin but it's probably not the only element. The toxin is a concentrated form of the flower and, probably, other chemicals.

The equivalent would be burning an opium poppy to taking heroin. You might be affected by burning the poppy but you're sure gonna feel something when taking heroin.

There's a wikia which suggest there are additional compounds in the gas/toxin

The gas is actually made from the Blue Poppies near Ra's al Ghul's dojo. Dr. Jonathan Crane is the corrupt chief therapist at Arkham Asylum, he has a vast amount of knowledge in science due to working with medicine for his patients. Crane makes an alliance with Ra's al Ghul and Falcone and uses the flowers to make his deadly fear toxin. Crane also has Falcone sneak in necessary ingredients for the toxin.




Pictures about "Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins?"

Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins? - White and Black Lego Blocks
Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins? - CCTV on Blue Wall
Why was Bruce not able to control his fears in Batman Begins? - Black and Gray Audio Mixer



What was Bruce afraid of in Batman Begins?

Both Batman and his enemies in this movie, be they the mob, Scarecrow or Ra's, utilize fear as a weapon, and fear drives the plot in many ways. It's Bruce's fear of bats that leads to his parents being killed in the alley that fateful night, leading to him partially blaming himself and looking to make it right.

How did Batman overcome his fear?

Eventually, Bruce decides to take something that once haunted him and turn this force against his enemies. In doing so he turned his greatest fear \u2014 bats \u2014 to work for him, eventually becoming a symbol for the protection of Gotham.

What was Bruce Wayne scared of?

Wayne's phobia of bats is the most apparent. It stems from his childhood incident of falling down a well with bats flying up above him.

What was Bruce Wayne doing in the beginning of Batman Begins?

After training with his mentor, Batman begins his fight to free crime-ridden Gotham City from corruption. When his parents are killed, billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne relocates to Asia, where he is mentored by Henri Ducard and Ra's Al Ghul in how to fight evil.



Batman Begins - To Conquer Fear - You Must Become Fear




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Diego Pontes, Diabetesmagazijn.nl, Jan van der Wolf, Dmitry Demidov