How realistic is the depiction of court proceedings in Law & Order?
I am wondering, how accurate is the depiction of the court proceedings in Law & Order?
By this I mean the vocabulary they use, and also if the sentences they make using that (legal) vocabulary have any resemblance whatsoever to what an actual lawyer might say in court.
Examples are:
Some lawyer says something to the judge and the judge says "So noted Mr. So and so". Do real courts do this?
What about the judge asking the jury things like "...murder in the second degree how do you find"? (apologies if I got the words wrong)
- Prosecutor says "Permission to treat this witness as hostile, your honour?"
- Judge says "Overruled" or "Sustained" when a lawyer interjects a comment opposing a question the opposition's lawyer has asked.
In response to comment: Yes, this question is about US courts.
In response to answer: Please include your qualifications if you answer this question. I am looking for an answer by someone with a legal background or similar qualification.
Also please note that I am aware of what my examples mean in the series. I am not asking for an explanation of their meaning.
Best Answer
Yes, L&O is fairly accurate about the common legal terms used.
So noted: It's been placed on the record for consideration.
Judge asking the Jury their finding on a specific charge.
A Lawyer needs permission from a Judge to treat a hostile witness as such, changing some rules on what and how the lawyer can ask certain questions. A specific legal term.
Overruled and Sustained are also specific legal terms regarding an Objection by a lawyer.
Most of these are fairly traditional key words. They don't have to phrase it like that exactly as long as they get the meaning across. A lawyer can object without referencing a specific objection type if the behavior objected to is blatant, and the judge can simply agree or tell the offending lawyer to move on. But as court cases become more serious, these terms are used more frequently out of formality.
Pictures about "How realistic is the depiction of court proceedings in Law & Order?"
What is the most realistic law show?
'Better Call Saul' Is The Most Accurate Legal Show On Television.Is Law and Order UK accurate?
In order to make the show as gritty and realistic as possible, "Law & Order" worked with many experts in the criminal justice system. The show hired former NYPD detectives to consult on the show and included actual attorneys in the writer's room to make sure the action and drama were accurate and true-to-life.What is the most important part of a court order?
The most important thing to remember is that the opinion written by the court - the part which actually constitutes the law- does not begin until the section marked "Opinion." Generally, the sections appearing before the "Opinion" are added by the publisher to aid in understanding the decision.What is the wig in Anatomy of a scandal?
Why do the Anatomy of a Scandal barristers wear wigs in court? Wigs are part of the uniform for barristers in the British court. Solicitors are not usually required to wear them. Judges also wear wigs, though theirs are generally fancier and more ornate.Real Lawyer Goes To Court in Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney • Professionals Play
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Towfiqu barbhuiya, EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA, EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA, Sora Shimazaki