Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice?

Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice? - Black mother changing diaper for baby

I am watching Modern family and I am currently on season 3. In Modern family, season 1 Lily is played by Jaden. In season 2 by Ella Hiller and from season 3 Aubrey Anderson-Emmons. What is the reason behind these frequent changes ? Did the creators want to show a much grown up Lily by season 3?



Best Answer

Looking up the character on Wikipedia reveals that twin actors Jaden and Ella Hiller were replaced by Aubrey Anderson-Emmons. The reasons cited were the twin actresses' mother claimed they did not enjoy acting anymore, thus they "retired", and the role was recast with Aubrey Anderson-Emmons as Lily, who was old enough to provide speaking lines for Lily for the first time in the show.

Going further as a general film production question, the simple matter is that the actor or actress must be able to meet the demands of the character they've been selected to portray. Should the production team feel they're not able to do that at any point, they have the option to recast the role (barring contractual agreements to the contrary).

These rules apply to child actors just as much as adult actors.

Case in point for an adult role, Eric Stoltz was cast to play Marty McFly in Back to the Future. Initially Zemeckis wanted Michael J. Fox, but Fox was unable to get time off from filming the TV show Family Ties, so they cast Stoltz instead. 4 weeks into filming they realized it wasn't going to work and opted to recast with Fox when he was available, even though reshoots would cost $3 million.




Pictures about "Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice?"

Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice? - Young father changing diaper of newborn baby
Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice? - From above excited young mother changing diaper and playing with adorable ethnic baby lying on linen on floor
Why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice? - Ethnic bearded man carrying small kid with painted face in crowd of protesting against policy





Why Lily From AT\u0026T Won't Show Her Body In Commercials Anymore




More answers regarding why did they change the child actress portraying Lily twice?

Answer 2

In most movies young children aren't good actors when they grow older and other actors suit the job better. Usually in shows each character is much older eventually reaching their real life age. So they usually switch the actors especially for young adolescent actors

Answer 3

Actually, they changed to Aubrey because they felt the original "lily" was a little too dull and didnt have enough life, for lack of better word. I watched the documentary.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: William Fortunato, Helena Lopes, Keira Burton, Ahmed akacha