Why do most space movies contain sound?

Why do most space movies contain sound? - Young woman watching movie in headphones in messy room

I do not understand why most space movies contain sound.

For Example: The Martian (2015), Moon (2009) Armageddon (1998) etc. These movies contain sound in space which does not make sense.

Well, there are a few space movies which are accurate in the sound thing: Interstellar and Gravity etc.

So why do most movies contain sound in space although that is completely unrealistic?



Best Answer

Because audiences expect it, and will enjoy the movie less if it's missing.

Sound is a very crucial form of information transmission for humans; we rely on sounds non-stop to process our environment, often without even realizing it. Movies take advantage of those often subconscious sound cues to bring out the intended emotions in a scene. They also rely on sound as a quick way to convey certain actions or events without having to waste dialogue.

For better or worse, we have been conditioned to expect some of those audio cues in certain points in a movie. Weapons make noise, explosions make noise, rockets make noise, etc.

If a filmmaker were to film, for example, a space battle without sound, it would have significantly less impact than the equivalent battle within an atmosphere, because our brains would find the noiseless environment eerie and unnerving. In fact, the few movies that have successfully portrayed the silence of space (such as 2001) were specifically going for that emotional response.

To be fair, it's somewhat strange that people single this aspect of space movies out of the dozens of mistakes we take for granted all the time. Guns don't work the way they do in movies; injuries don't work the way they do in movies; cars rarely work the way they do in movies; computers don't work the way they do in movies; explosions don't work the way they do in movies. Sound in space is just one more thing on that very long list.




Pictures about "Why do most space movies contain sound?"

Why do most space movies contain sound? - Rule of Thirds Photography of Brown Wooden Table
Why do most space movies contain sound? - Various tool bits on white background
Why do most space movies contain sound? - Black Sand Dunes



Why are there sounds in space movies?

The common explanation for this is that space is a vacuum and so there's no medium for sound to travel through. Despite this, films have always depicted space as a noisy environment filled with booming sound effects.

Why are movies wrong when they show space explosions with sound?

To travel to us from outer space, the wave must be able to travel through regions of space which are essentially vacuum (nothing there). Sound cannot do this, as it requires a medium to propagate in, so we would not be able to hear the explosion. This is one mistake.

Why do many movie scenes go completely quiet when they are set in the vacuum of space?

The vacuum of outer space has essentially zero air. Because sound is just vibrating air, space has no air to vibrate and therefore no sound. If you are sitting in a space ship and another space ship explodes, you would hear nothing.

Does space sound like nothing?

No, there isn't sound in space. This is because sound travels through the vibration of particles, and space is a vacuum. On Earth, sound mainly travels to your ears by way of vibrating air molecules, but in near-empty regions of space there are no (or very, very few) particles to vibrate \u2013 so no sound.



The Sounds of Space: A sonic adventure to other worlds




More answers regarding why do most space movies contain sound?

Answer 2

There is sound 'in space', up to a point.

Sound can't propagate through a vacuum, because you can't make anything vibrate.
Sound can be propagated through objects that happen to be surrounded by vacuum, and/or the air inside those objects - wearing a spacesuit, you can hear the machinery in the suit, or someone tapping on it, or the radio mounted in it. If you were walking on Mars, you'd be able to hear your own footsteps.

On floors that vibrate (Sci-fi metal!), you could hear the footsteps of people nearby. You could certainly hear the engines of any ship you were in.

I don't remember any scene in The Martian with unrealistic sound - everything audible makes sense from Watney's (or someone else's) perspective.

EDIT: As commented, Mars isn't technically a vacuum, but the atmospheric pressure is less than 1% of Earth's, so human-audible sound wouldn't travel over any meaningful distance. People wearing helmets can still hear things, as described above.

(Aside, the ship-blowing-over thing in The Martian is the only really wrong thing in that movie because of this. They even make the point later, where a tarp will work because of the thin atmosphere).

EDIT2: On further reading, the density of Mars' atmosphere is about 7% of Earth's because it's almost all CO², so you actually could hear loud sounds over a few metres.

Answer 3

In movies, it is extremely common to have a "virtual microphone" which is much closer to the action than the camera. If a football movie included a conversation between a couple players that was filmed using a telephoto lens from 200 feet away, it would generally be absurd to suggest that the dialogue should sound like it would sound from the point of view of the visual observer (including a 0.2-second delay). Instead, the sound should be as perceived by the characters who are the center of attention. When several characters in the scene merit attention, sound that would be audible at any of them may be audible to the audience.

It's entirely plausible that firing the weapons on a space fighter might cause significant vibrations in the frame which would be perceived as sound to anyone inside. The sound may not be audible to any other participant in the battle, but it would be difficult to really convey the idea that each participant would be hearing a different set of sounds. It's much easier and practical to let the audience hear sounds that some involved character would hear.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Andrea Piacquadio, Dương Nhân, Ksenia Chernaya, Adrien Olichon