If there's only one timeline, why did the Ancient One beg to differ?
While If there's only one timeline, how could Doctor Strange have seen 14 million of them? was theoretical (people commented Doctor Strange may have seen only potential timelines), if there is only one true Sacred Timeline according to the Time Variance Authority (TVA), then why did the Ancient One clearly state exactly the opposite about her actual timeline?
The Infinity Stones create what you experience as the flow of time. Remove one stone and that flow splits. Now, this may benefit your reality but my new one, not so much. In this new branched reality, without our chief weapon against the forces of darkness, our world will be over run. Millions will suffer. So, tell me Doctor, can your science prevent all that?
Best Answer
What she was saying is not incongruent with the TVA. Without the TVA there could be millions of timelines, right? The TVA just enforces the 'main' one (whatever they determine that is). When you mess with time you create the potentials for variants - the Ancient One was essentially saying that when you take out the time stone then the Hulk would be creating a variant timeline; her new one since, presumably, she knows how her timeline is supposed to go. She's supposed to deliver the time stone to doctor strange and then die in the hospital.
Doctor Strange saw 14 million potential timelines. He didn't have access to know which was the 'official' TVA timeline - which is presumably the one that occurred in End Game - he just saw 14 million variant potentials.
Pictures about "If there's only one timeline, why did the Ancient One beg to differ?"
Why did they change the Ancient One?
Tilda Swinton said she questioned her casting as the Ancient One in "Doctor Strange." The film was accused of whitewashing because Swinton's character was a Tibetan man in the comics. Marvel Studios chief Kevin Feige previously told Men's Health that he regretted this choice.Does the Ancient One know about the sacred timeline?
Looking back at it now, the Ancient One was essentially showing Banner the Sacred Timeline. She continued by demonstrating the branch that would be created by her giving him the Time Stone and discussed its impacts. Neither the TVA nor the Sacred Timeline were mentioned in this scene.Why did Ancient One split the timeline?
However, the Ancient One (Tilda Swinton) explains that Palmer's death is an absolute point in time, and reversing it could destroy the universe. To stop Doctor Strange, the Ancient One splits him into two, allowing a good Doctor Strange and an evil one to live out two different timelines.Why is the Ancient One alive in endgame?
By drawing power and energy from the Dark Dimension, she was able to prolong her lifespan indefinitely. If she'd kept out of danger, she would've been technically immortal. In the end, though, she accepted her fate: \u201cWe don't get to choose our time. Death is what gives life meaning.The Weeknd - I Was Never There feat. Gesaffelstein (Official Audio)
More answers regarding if there's only one timeline, why did the Ancient One beg to differ?
Answer 2
Infinity stones are very capable of creating branched timelines.
The TVA has a desk draw filled with a host of infinity stones, presumably from pruned timelines where they were used for the wrong purpose. Timestones are very able to generate variant energy and create new timelines if used for the wrong purpose due to their immense power, like the other infinity stones. As such, the timestone being able to simulate these other timelines it could create is a pretty understandable power.
If he did create these timelines then he would be pruned, but he has the freedom of choice to create them. The infinity stone isn't necessarily able to predict well the actions of the TVA since their home is immune to its powers and so he might not see himself being pruned.
The Ancient One may well have some idea about the TVA.
The Loki writers hinted she did.
"We don't really know. It would be interesting if they did," Waldron told The Direct. "I think what we see with the TVA is, whereas the folks at Kamar-Taj are dealing things in a magical way, the TVA is paperwork. It's bureaucracy. It appears to be a little more science-based."
If she did know about them, her statement is accurate. Their branch may be pruned by the TVA, and millions would suffer.
She doesn't necessarily know the full picture. She sees things from a magic side of things, which may well carry hints, but not all of the picture. -- Doctor Strange.
The Ancient One: Each of those maps was drawn up by someone who could see in part, but not the whole.
Dr. Stephen Strange: I spent my last dollar getting here on a one-way ticket, and you’re talking to me about healing through belief?
The Ancient One: You’re a man who’s looking at the world through a keyhole, and you spent your whole life trying to widen that keyhole. To see more, know more. And now, on hearing that it can be widened in ways you can’t imagine, you reject the possibility?
In Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness we may see how much they know about the TVA. What they do know will likely be mystical, not scientific.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Miguel Á. Padriñán, Wendy Wei, Anna Shvets, Matthias Groeneveld