Is this an inconsistency in the Infinity War and Guardians of the Galaxy?
In Infinity War, Thanos explains to Gamora that killing half of her people saved them from inevitable doom.
You know what's happened since then? The children born have known nothing but full bellies and clear skies. It's a paradise.
Further, we see flashbacks that he indeed kills half of the population. But, in Guardians of the Galaxy, when a profile of Gamora is shown while she enters the prison with Star Lord, it says that she is
the last survivor of the Zehoberei people
Was this an oversight in either movie?
Best Answer
The destruction of the Zehoberei people may have come long after Thanos' attack on the planet. Gamora was only a little girl when it happened, and it doesn't appear that Thanos revisited her planet after the genocide.
Edit: Thanos never says when he went back to her planet. Estimates put her age at 26 during IW, and she looks to be around 8-10 when Thanos kidnaps her. Even if we knock off a couple of years to account for GotG, an extremely conservative estimate puts the time range at 10 years between kidnap and IW. That's a long time for catastrophes to happen.
I'm not saying Thanos' strategy killed her people. I'm saying that Thanos went back after he halved their population, observed that they were thriving, left, and then a catastrophe befell them that killed the entire population.
Pictures about "Is this an inconsistency in the Infinity War and Guardians of the Galaxy?"
Is Guardians of the Galaxy relevant to Age of Ultron?
Though Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 is the latest adventure in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, chronologically it's actually a prequel to Avengers: Age of Ultron, Captain America: Civil War, Ant-Man, and Doctor Strange. That's right.Did Thanos get an Infinity Stone in Guardians of the Galaxy?
In Avengers: Infinity War, it is revealed that the Power Stone was the first to be obtained by Thanos, who "decimates" Xandar in the process. Thanos uses the Stone to destroy the Statesman and during the battle on Titan against Tony Stark and members of the Guardians.Is Thanos the same in Guardians of the Galaxy?
With the help of his adopted children and after a significant conflict against various entities including the Avengers, the Guardians of the Galaxy, and their allies, Thanos is successful in assembling the Stones within his Infinity Gauntlet and erasing half of all life in the universe....Thanos (Marvel Cinematic Universe)ThanosHomeTitan Garden14 more rowsWhy does Thanos look different in Infinity War?
Thanos, however, drew the shorter stick and inherited the Deviant gene, still diluted in the Eternals and capable of emerging from time to time. That's why Thanos looks like a giant purple guy; Thanos' Deviant gene deformed his appearance.Avengers vs Guardians of the Galaxy Full Scene - Avengers Infinity War Movie Clip HD [1080p 50FPS]
More answers regarding is this an inconsistency in the Infinity War and Guardians of the Galaxy?
Answer 2
To offer a theory: as a planet conquerer, Thanos could have renamed the surviving half of the Zehoberei people, seeing them as a new race with a new future, leaving his mark of salvation on them. As Thanos would be a feared and renowned conquerer throughout the universe, the rest of the universe would recognize this change as absolute. Gamora, being loyal to her family and hating Thanos, would still call herself a Zehoberei. Therefore, Gamora would be seen as the last survivor of the people she still claims to be a part of.
Answer 3
I don't see how that's an inconsistency. The fact that Thanos believes in, and propagates, a genocidal Malthusian ideology doesn't mean that he's right. It would only be an oversight if
- You accept Thanos' premise that this is the only way to save life in the universe, and
- You believe his plan is infallible, meaning that once he killed half the population of a world, nothing else could happen to eradicate that world's population.
I don't accept #1 (which is a silly argument for many reasons), and certainly #2 is obviously false - Thanos doesn't promise eternal success for any planet, just removes what is (to his mind) the biggest reason for failure.
His actions might have (to his mind, again) saved the Zenoberi from collapse. They might have died out later on for other reasons.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Faik Akmd, Philippe Donn, stein egil liland, Felix Mittermeier