Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate]

Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate] - Cute siblings using tablet together at home

Both The Illusionist and The Prestige are about turn of the century performing magicians, and were released not even two months apart from each other; the former was released September 1st, 2006, and the latter on October 20th, 2006.

The fact that they're both about turn of the century magicians -- and that there really aren't any other movies in 2006 that use this general plot -- it strikes me as somewhat unique that these two movies were created and released so close in time to one another.

When looking to directors/production crews for similarities, I'm not able to find anything that stands out..

The Illusionist:

  • Bull's Eye Entertainment
  • Bob Yari Productions
  • Contagious Entertainment
  • Michael London Productions
  • Stillking Films

The Prestige:

  • Touchstone Pictures (presents)
  • Warner Bros. (presents)
  • Newmarket Productions (as Newmarket Films)
  • Syncopy

So, how/why did these two magician films get created and released at nearly the same time?

Is this purely coincidence (in which case, that's a perfectly acceptable answer), or, are these movies related in some way? Perhaps, one inspired the other, or, they were apart of a larger "movement/release" of magician films that didn't really take?



Best Answer

I will call it:

Coincident.

And this is not the only time it happened but it happens quite frequently and there is a term for such films: Twin films.

Similar example is No Strings Attached and Friends with Benefits. Both tackle the same subject and from same genre romcom. Also it happened with Hercules and The Legend of Hercules which both centered around the same demigod.

We don't know the exact reason why it happens but there are some speculations:

Some attribute twin films to industrial espionage, the movement of staff between studios, or that the same screenplays are sent to several film studios before being accepted. Another possible explanation is if the films deal with topical issues, such as volcanic eruptions, reality television, terrorist attacks or significant anniversaries, resulting in multiple discovery of the concept. *

Even Disney and WB almost did it with Jungle book story but then WB pushed it for later and renamed it.

BBC explain similar cases in there article and the most controversial one is:

A Bug's Life & Antz

A row broke out between Pixar bosses Steve Jobs and John Lasseter and DreamWorks CEO Jeffrey Katzenberg, who had left Disney's film division to set up a rival company. Jobs and Lasseter claimed Katzenberg had stolen their idea, which Katzenberg denied. The press revelled in how dirty the fighting got, with Katzenberg bringing forward the release date for Antz by six months to beat A Bug's Life into cinemas. Antz was a box office success, but it didn't harm the Pixar film which eventually made more than twice as much as its rival did.

Similar posts:

Why are two Jungle book movies being made consecutively?

Similarities of Pixar and Dreamworks: any published explanation?




Pictures about "Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate]"

Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate] - Close-Up Photo of Clock Pointing at 2
Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate] - Person Holding Black and White Bottle
Two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate] - Two Coffee Latte



What other magic movie came out at the same time as The Prestige?

The script was based loosely on "Eisenheim the Illusionist", a short story by Steven Millhauser from Millhauser's 1990 collection The Barnum Museum. Together with The Prestige and Scoop, The Illusionist was one of three films in 2006 to explore the world of stage magicians.

What two movies have the same plot?

Sometimes, movies released in different years, like "The Wild" (2006) and"Madagascar" (2005), also share similar plots. Other movies, like "First Daughter" (2004) nor "Chasing Liberty" (2004) were released shortly after each other and share almost identical plots. Visit Insider's homepage for more stories.

What movie came out at the same time as the illusionist?

2006: "The Prestige" and "The Illusionist" both captivated us with magic. Christian Bale and Hugh Jackman's film about the competition between two magicians narrowly edged out Edward Norton's about using magic solely for love at theaters.



The Return of Abhimanyu (Irumbu Thirai) 2019 New Released Full Hindi Dubbed Movie | Vishal, Samantha




More answers regarding two magician films released nearly the same time.. any connection? [duplicate]

Answer 2

It appears just to have been a coincidence

Sometimes writers just happen to be working on movies at the same time with little to no knowledge of similar projects.

The Illusionist and The Prestige are not very similar movies, but they do suffer that stereotype because they’re about stage magicians and happened to be released near the end of 2006. Apparently Christopher and Jonathan Nolan had been working on the screenplay for years and finally finished it in time for the Fall movie season.

Whereas, The Illusionist won over crowds in early 2006 at Sundance and was bought for release which coincidentally happened two months before the Prestige.

Source

This is not uncommon.

Obvious examples are:

  • Volcano & Dante's Peak
  • Flight 93 & United 93
  • Armageddon & Deep Impact

On at least one occasion, movies were based on similar books and two studios co-operated in making one blockbuster movie rather than cannibalise each others profits.

The Towering Inferno

Warner Brothers outbid Fox to obtain the rights to Stern's The Tower for $400,000. Fox, in turn, spent $300,000[14] to obtain the rights to Scortia's The Glass Inferno. Irwin Allen realized that two films about a tall building on fire would cannibalize each other (as actually happened a couple decades later in the case of the two films about active volcanoes, released nearly simultaneously, Volcano (released by Fox) and Dante's Peak (released by Universal)[15]), convinced executives at both studios to join forces to make a single film on the subject.

Wikpedia

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Victoria Art, Skitterphoto, Artem Podrez, Anna Urlapova