How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor?

How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor? - Beige Sofa Chair Near A Table

The Tesseract ends up on earth because it was lost during the battle between Odin and the Frost Giants.

During Thor we see Thor talking (as a child) about how he wants to wage war on the Frost giants, like his father (Odin). So we know that the Tesseract must have been lost already.

But, during Thor's coronation ceremony, we see some frost giants trying to steal the Tesseract from Odin's throne room (or wherever that was), even though we know that it was lost.

The Tesseract wasn't returned to Odin's throne room until after the events of the Avengers, which we know came after Thor, because Thor only decided to become a superhero on Earth after the events of Thor. Can anyone explain what's going on here?



Best Answer

During Thor we see Thor talking (as a child) about how he wants to wage war on the Frost giants, like his father (Odin). So we know that the Tesseract must have been lost already.

Actually, what this shows us is that this is happening over a thousand years in the past.

  • When Dr. Selvig is in the library, we see a book of Norse mythology. It has a picture of a full-grown Thor.
  • Due to the mixture of real-world mythology, and the Marvel universe, the Asgardians were active on Earth about a thousand years ago, to jibe with our real-world history. It was during this time they lost the Tesseract on Earth during the war with the Frost Giants.
  • This means that ~1000 years ago, Thor looked like a teenager or young human, at least. This is because ~1000 years ago the Norse peoples interacted with Thor, and passed around stories of him as a full-height person, not a short child. This then trickled down through time as Norse mythology

So in the scene with child Thor and child Loki, it's entirely possible that the Tesseract would be in the trophy room, since it hadn't yet been lost on Earth. However:

BUT, during Thor's coronation ceremony, we see some frost giants trying to steal the Tesseract from Odin's throne room (or wherever that was), even though we know that it was lost.

No, during this scene they attempt to steal the Casket of Ancient Winters. It's the device that allows the wielder to make blasts of severe cold. This is the device that later on Loki takes and uses to freeze several things, including Heimdall and the Rainbow Bridge device.

The Tesseract is a device that emits vast amounts of energy, and can be used to travel between the realms. This device was central to the plot of Avengers, and Captain America. It was not seen in Thor, except during the post-credits scene.




Pictures about "How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor?"

How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor? -  Flower Vase And Lamp On Black Vase on A Console Table
How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor? - Close-up of Paper Against Black Background
How is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor? - Empty Bedroom Set



How is the Tesseract in Asgard in Thor?

The Tesseract was brought to Earth from Asgard by Odin. It remained in a temple in a small village for several centuries. It was later found by HYDRA and taken by force and used as a power source for a super weapon which could destroy almost anything upon impact.

Did Odin have the Tesseract in Thor?

With the Bifrost Bridge still destroyed, Thor, who had been sent back to Earth in The Avengers by Odin's dark magic, used the Tesseract to transport himself and Loki back to Asgard. Over a thousand years later, the Tesseract was back in Asgard and given a cushy spot in Odin's vault.



Explaining the Confusing Tesseract Timeline




More answers regarding how is the Tesseract still in Odin's trophy room during Thor?

Answer 2

Reading up on this Marvel Universe article about Cosmic Cubes tells us that there is possibly more than one cube in the universe itself.

If we are to believe that the Cinematic Universe (Earth-199999 as it is known in the Marvel Multi-verse) has similar canon then we can assume the same to be true that there is more than one Tesseract a.k.a. Cosmic Cube a.k.a. ooo shiny.

Also, things that I have been looking up state that the Cubes in this universe were actually Asgardian artefacts created by Odin himself. Therefore we can assume the one found on Earth was just a remnant of the time when Odin was on Earth, creating the illusion of Norse mythology to the people and uses these cubes (several? a few? who knows) to power Asgard itself and the Bifrost.

I hope to add more info when I go home and get some screen-grabs of Thor as well as hope to add more when Thor 2 comes out.


Further, memories are serving me at the moment that the artefact that the Frost Giants were stealing during the coronation was not actually a Tesseract/Cosmic Cube but actually an artefact of the Frost Giant's creation that maybe powered their world or contained something relating to their own people that Odin obtained to signify the end of the Asgard/Frost Giant war.

Looking on, it seems the item confiscated from the Jotuns was actually the Cask of Ancient Winters which gave the Jotuns power.

Another artefact spotted in that scene is the Orb of Agamotto used by another Marvel character in the Comic's canon.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Mikhail Nilov, Mikhail Nilov, John-Mark Smith, Victoria Art