Is Independence Day a comedy spoof?
I haven't seen it since I walked out of the theater disgusted in 1996, but I've recently been wondering if the movie Independence Day was intended to be a comedy.
I was 19 then, and I went to see Independence Day expecting a serious sci-fi-action movie. Perhaps I had been led on by the super-cool previews that showed the aliens blowing up key Earth landmarks. In any case, my fan-boy soul was pretty much crushed by the movie's sheer ridiculousness, including:
- when Will Smith punched an alien and then got excited about it
- how the plot hinged on a human computer being able to plug right in to the alien mainframe and upload "jollyroger.exe"
- the shameless product placement surrounding that human computer
- everything involving characters played by Brent Spiner and Randy Quaid
I don't remember too many details, but I do remember thoroughly despising the movie, cursing its makers, and casting a dismissive eye on the many people who gushed about how cool it was.
But did I miss something? Was Independence Day intended to be a comedy -- a spoof of the sci-fi-action genre? Maybe the moments that made me cringe were meant to make me laugh? Anything out there on this?
Best Answer
I think that the movie was expressively designed to be entertaining and break records set by Jurassic Park a couple of years earlier. You might also remember the impressive marketing campaign and hype that preceeded the release of the film. Considering that the target audience was everybody, things had to be dumbed down to be accessible to everybody.
In 1996, Will Smith hadn't hit the big leagues yet and was coming off the success of Bad Boys, a comedy where he plays the "cool and funny". His role in ID4 isn't much different.
So, no. I don't think ID4 is a spoof. It's simply a commercial sci/fi film loaded with special effects and cheesy dialogue, designed to appeal to a larger audience. Much the same as MiB would be a year or so later.
Pictures about "Is Independence Day a comedy spoof?"
Is Independence Day a spoof?
A "mockumentary" of the alien invasion during Independence Day. Barry Nolan hosts the programme, the first 9 minutes of which are a spoof news report of the events of the film.Is Independence Day a scary movie?
Lots of fun, but too scary for some kids.What is Independence Day based on?
The character was based on one of Dean Devlin's uncles. Robert Loggia as General William Grey, USMC, the Commandant of the United States Marine Corps. Loggia modeled the character after World War II generals, particularly George S. Patton.What is the message of Independence Day movie?
Share All sharing options for: The movie Independence Day teaches us that victory is more important than principles. The hostile alien intruders in the film Independence Day caught the world by surprise, arriving like a well-coordinated swarm of locusts to wipe out humanity and take all our natural resources.A Bill Pullman Independence Day NYC
More answers regarding is Independence Day a comedy spoof?
Answer 2
The film isn't a spoof (at least like the Naked Gun), but the pitch would have been something along the lines of
Do a fifties B Flying Saucer movie in the present day
For example, one of the most famous one's is this (with special effects by Ray Harryhausen no less):
This famously had similar imagery of iconic buildings being destroyed:
What else did films of the era have? Well:
- A heroic lead character
- An aloof but brilliant scientist who comes up with some fantastic solution based on his "observations"
- A romantic partner for the lead, who ends up in distress
- An authority figure, usually portrayed in a heroic light
- A guest star, usually a popular music face of the day, maybe just in a cameo role
Looking at ID4, we have all these elements, but of course given the more modern timeframe there are wrinkles to the cliches:
- The Hero is black
- The hero's love is a single parent and "exotic" dancer
- The scientist is a Nerd and with parent issues
- There is another scientist who turns out to both know about the aliens and has been examining them for many years, but is completely useless at helping them in their fight.
- The authority figure is human, his failures (as a president) surpass his successes.
- The character who makes the heroic sacrifice is an alcoholic and poor parent.
- The cameo music star is Harry Connick Jnr, not really a teen idol.
Also given the more modern setting, we add some things from subsequent defining dramas, for example the whole Area 51/government cover up stuff a la the X Files.
So while not a spoof the film is essentially a mega budget B Movie, and belief should be suspended when watching, just enjoy the roller coaster ride.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Karolina Grabowska, Brett Sayles, Sharefaith, Brett Sayles