Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2?

Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2? - Silver MacBook on White Table

I am a bit confused with the The Flash/Supergirl crossover. I always thought Supergirl was Earth-1, but The Flash rescued her and implied that she was Earth-2. If she is Earth-2 and The Flash has rescued her by accidentally crossing over to Earth-2, what is that thing on his chest? The tachyon accelerator Dr. Well was talking about in the Flash Back episode of The Flash? I thought the purpose of that device was making him faster? How did he change his frequency enough to change Earths?



Best Answer

Supergirl happens in one of the various unnumbered parallel universes to The Flash and the Arrow-verse. It is neither Earth-1, where Arrow, The Flash, Vixen, or Legends of Tomorrow occur, nor Earth-2, home to Jay/Zoom, the 2nd Harrison Wells, and Jessie Quick, where technology seems to have taken off decades earlier (Very Zee-Rust).

Update: A season later, they explicitly name it Earth-38.

As Barry so non-eloquently tries to explain to the Supergirl scoobies, just as Dr. Stein did to the Flash scoobies:
enter image description here enter image description here

The Supergirl universe has no Flash, or Arrow or other related heroes or villains. Just like Earth-1 has no active Batman, Green Lantern, or Superman/Supergirl, though there are name drops. Unlike Earth-2, where everyone seems to have a doppelgänger, Supergirl does not have some of the key people from Earth-1:

You guys have Central City but you don't have S.T.A.R. Labs. No Cisco Ramon, no Harrison Wells, no Caitlin Snow. Nobody who's gonna be able to help me get back home.

There are also other Earths that were seen when Barry time travels or when they used the Speed Canon. The original 1990 The Flash is one of them (Where the actor who is Barry's dad in Earth-1 is the Flash.) Supergirl is the other. A future where there is a Black Green Arrow (Conner Hawke, as seen on Legends of Tomorrow).

Barry mentions a world where Nazis win WW2 (As seen on Justice League episodes "The Savage Time"), and one where Kennedy doesn't die. There is also a parallel universe where everyone is evil, but it apparently sucks. In the regular comics, this is Earth-3 where the Crime Syndicate of America exists, but this may be a reference to Earth-2, but not everyone there is evil, so it may be another Earth. These are either examples that he comes up with, or are Earths he visits or sees prior to landing on Supergirl's Earth.

In Supergirl, they specifically mention the concept of Infinite Earths, referring to the DC multiverse with an infinite number of parallel universes (prior to the current New 52 concept). Dr. Stein also mentioned "parallel Earths to infinity." in s02e02 "Flash of Two Worlds".

How the Flash gets to these parallel Earths will be shown in s02e18 "Versus Zoom", which airs April 19. They took a few weeks off. The Supergirl crossover was not aired in continuity order. Evidently, "Worlds' Finest" happens in between 5m03s and 5m05s of The Flash episode, when Barry portals out and back in while testing the Tachyon Enhancer.

But given the previews, the previous The Flash episodes and the Supergirl episode, the device on Barry's chest is clearly the Tachyon Enhancer that Reverse-Flash used and eventually gave the specs to future-Barry in s02e17 "Flash Back". As he says in Worlds' Finest, he's been trying to run faster and ran fast enough to break through to the parallel world. By accident:

Wynn: Okay. So you can just like, just hop back and forth between universes?
Barry: Uh, no actually. This happened by accident. I have traveled through time before by accident.
Wynn: That's cool.
Barry: I've never jumped parallel dimensions without meaning to. So until I can figure this out, I'm stuck here.

In "Versus Zoom", Cisco outright calls it the Tachyon Enhancer, and when Barry finally gets back to Star Labs, he says:

Barry: I'm back. [Puzzled Look]
What... how long was I gone?

The most direct reference to the cross over. It also implies that Barry Time Traveled when he jumped Earths, or that time flows differently on Supergirl's Earth, as the events of "Worlds' Finest" clearly took over several days, a week tops.




Pictures about "Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2?"

Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2? - Top view of empty dry plain surface of beach covered with sand in daytime
Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2? - From above of crop faceless female gardener planting seedling during work in countryside
Is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2? - From above of miniature toys tipi house and American Indian family placed near vintage globe against gray background at daytime



Is there a Supergirl on Earth-1?

The last daughter of Krypton of her universe. This Kara Zor-El ulike her counterpart Kara Danvers was not raised by humans on the contrary she was captured by the U.S. government and the subject of cruel, degrading, and inhumane experiments....Kara Zor-El (Earth-1)Kara Zor-ElAlter egoUltragirlActorMelissa BenoistSource7 more rows

Is Kara Danvers from Earth-1?

Species. Earth-38 was one of the many universes in the multiverse. It was the home universe of Superman and Supergirl. During the Anti-Monitor Crisis, the entire universe was engulfed in a wave of antimatter, with 3 billion of Earth's citizens surviving due to evacuation to Earth-1, making them refugees.

Is Supergirl from another Earth?

Supergirl joined The CW in Fall 2016, but it still remains separate from the other three series as it takes place in a different in a different dimension. Arrow, Flash, and Legends of Tomorrow are all set on Earth-1 while Supergirl is set on Earth-38.



The Flash Travels to Earth Thirty Eight and Returns to Earth One




More answers regarding is Supergirl from Earth-1 or Earth-2?

Answer 2

In The Flash Season 3 Episode 8, Cisco and Barry are trying to recruit Supergirl and Cisco says that the tachyon device tracked Barry to Earth-38 when he visited Supergirl the first time.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Andrew Neel, Laker, Karolina Grabowska, Tatiana Syrikova