Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions

Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions - Top view of paper world map with continents and different countries oceans and seas placed in sunny room

In The Crown, season 4, The Prime Minster refuses to sign a document towards sanctions in South Africa. The Queen was rather insistent that this was really important for the commonwealth.

  • what are these ‘sanctions’?
  • why didn’t she want to sign it?

She was rather forced into signing only after the declaration was rewritten several times.


I am afraid this has rather gone over my head.



Best Answer

What are sanctions?

Economic Sanctions is a method of pressure against the government of another country:

Economic sanctions are commercial and financial penalties applied by one or more countries against a targeted self-governing state, group, or individual. Economic sanctions are not necessarily imposed because of economic circumstances—they may also be imposed for a variety of political, military, and social issues. Economic sanctions can be used for achieving domestic and international purposes

So in short, it is an agreement between a group of countries saying that they won't do business with the target country unless it will do (or stop doing) something, for example, stop persecuting minorities, adhere to international law etc. In effect, the targeted country cannot earn money from exporting its own goods and cannot import goods that it doesn't produce, which cripples its economy.

In the case of South Africa, the reason behind the sanction was the policy of Apartheid - a system of institutionalized racial segregation within that country and repeated breaches against human rights.

What were the sanctions against South Africa

South Africa was sanctioned many times with limited success - you can find the comprehensive list here. The ones mentioned in The Crown are most likely those ones:

August 4, 1986: Seven members of the Commonwealth group of nations meet in London. Six of the seven agree to restrict their imports of South African agricultural goods, uranium, coal, and iron and steel. The United Kingdom was the nation that did not agree to these sanctions

Why Thatcher didn't agree to those sanctions?

There were two main reasons for that:

Maggie was really trying to Make Britain Great Again 1 This means she was refusing to do anything that would hurt the economy of the United Kingdom: if you refuse to buy and sell goods to the sanctioned country, you will be losing money too. And since the economy of the UK was already fragile, she didn't want to do anything that would risk it(especially when you notice that the proposed ban was affecting such critical goods as uranium or platinum) in the name of such notions as Human Rights 2. It is also worth to point, that her son was personally doing business within South Africa, so the effects of her sanctions could hit quite close to home.

The second reason is a bit more complicated and sensitive: In 1980s Great Britain was involved in undeclared war in Northern Ireland: broadly speaking, the Protestants wanted to remain as a part of the UK, while the Catholics wanted to unite Ireland. To pressure the government, IRA has performed a bombing campaign against economical and political targets (including Thatcher herself). The same was doing the ANC - the organization fighting for the rights of the black majority within South Africa. Thatcher was condemning both IRA and ANC3 , going as far as calling Nelson Mandela "a terrorist", which means that she somehow had to agree with the methods used by the Apartheid government.

Tl;dr

The sanctions were severely restricting trade with South Africa. Margaret Thatcher didn't want to agree to them, because they would hurt the UK and she had a degree of sympathy towards the South African government

1 - This is not a parody of Trump's "MAGA" - Margaret Thatcher has used those exact words as early as 1950.

2 - However you want to remember Thatcher, she has done some questionable things, especially towards the poorer part of the population. Friendly visits with Augusto Pinochet (who was at that time under arrest accused of breaking human rights) suggest that this wasn't as high on her list as economy

3 - The fact that ANC was sympathizing with Soviet Union didn't help either. Remember, that this is still Cold War period!




Pictures about "Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions"

Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions - Old world map placed on wall
Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions - From above of sunlit aged paper world map with continents countries and oceans
Mrs. Thatcher and South Africa’s sanctions - Grey Rhinoceros on Brown Field



Did Great Britain ever impose sanctions on South Africa?

In August 1986, however, UK sanctions against apartheid South Africa were extended to include a "voluntary ban" on tourism and new investments. Since the fall of the apartheid system, South Africa has returned to the Commonwealth of Nations as a republic in the Commonwealth of Nations.

Who imposed sanctions South Africa?

The Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986 was a law enacted by the United States Congress. The law imposed sanctions against South Africa and stated five preconditions for lifting the sanctions that would essentially end the system of apartheid, which the latter was under at the time.

What happened between Margaret Thatcher and the Queen?

A notorious 1986 report in the Sunday Times, headlined "Queen dismayed by 'uncaring' Thatcher," was among the flashpoints in their time working together\u2014understandably, as it claimed that the Queen, who has always done her best to stay out of politics, staunchly disagreed with the Prime Minister's refusal to impose ...

Why was South Africa removed from the Commonwealth?

While Commonwealth conferences were normally held biennially, this conference was held after an interval of only a year as the May 1960 conference due to disagreement over South Africa and whether the country should be removed from the Commonwealth due to its policy of racial segregation with Malaya's Prime Minister ...



F.W. de Klerk: Thatcher \




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Nothing Ahead, Nothing Ahead, Nothing Ahead, Tom D'Arby