Scott Summers's status in X-Men: The Last Stand?
In the movie X-Men: The Last Stand the resurrected Jean Grey comes back as the Phoenix and kills both Scott Summers and Xavier becoming being killed herself by the Wolverine.
I've seen many examples of Xavier living in the future war with the Sentinels in both the movies, comic books and other alternative time lines of the X-Men. In the Last Stand movie Scott Summers's death isn't actually shown on screen, and none of the characters actually say that he's dead.
Is there anything in the comics or cut scenes for the movie that would clarify that he's really dead, and doesn't come back like Xavier does?
Best Answer
Yes, it's pretty definite that Jean killed Scott. She never comes right out and says it, since her Dark Phoenix persona remains dominant for most of the movie, but there are several lines of dialogue that make it clear that's what happened.
Jean almost admits what she did in the exchange with Logan, when she returns to the X Mansion. Dark Phoenix Jean starts to come on to him very strongly, but when he backs off, she seems to "regain her senses", followed by this dialogue:
LOGAN: Where's Scott? Jean?
JEAN: Where am I?
LOGAN: You're in the mansion. You need to tell me what happened to Scott. Jean, tell me what happened to him.
JEAN: Oh, God.
LOGAN: Look at me. Stay with me. Talk to me. Look at me. Look at me.
JEAN: No... (starts to weep) Kill me.
LOGAN: What?
JEAN: Kill me before I kill someone else.
Right after this, Jean seems to return to her Dark Phoenix state and leaves. Xavier then finds Logan and, who says:
ORORO: What happened?
CHARLES: What have you done?
LOGAN: I think she killed Scott.
Later, when Xavier tracks Jean down at the house, and tries to convince her to get help controlling her power, one of the things he says is:
CHARLES: Trust me. You're a danger to everyone. But I can help you.
ERIC: I think you want to give her the cure.
XAVIER: Look at Scott. You killed the man you loved because you couldn't control your power.
JEAN: No! Stop it!
Admittedly she's in a bad condition at this point, but she doesn't seem to be denying the act so much as trying to get Charles to stop talking about it, and stop trying to "get in her head".
On a closely related note, the events of this movie were essentially erased from the timeline by X-Men: Days of Future Past. The ending of that movie shows both Jean and Scott alive and well at the X Mansion, and apparently happily together as a couple.
Pictures about "Scott Summers's status in X-Men: The Last Stand?"
What happened to Scott in X-Men Last Stand?
The first casualty is Scott, destroyed by Dark Phoenix right after his joyful discovery that Jean lives. Mystique gets shot with the cure while protecting Magneto, only for him to be shot with it later on. Phoenix destroys Charles in her childhood home, leaving the X-Men more lost and devastated than ever.Does Scott come back to life X-Men?
After Marvel teased his return all fall, we got our first glimpse of the resurrected mutant leader in the final issue of the Extermination miniseries. This week, Uncanny X-Men Annual #1 gives us the full story of how Scott Summers, killed in 2016's Death of X #1, is back among the living.What happens to Scott Summers?
Scott suffered a head injury on landing that damaged the part of Scott's brain that would have enabled him to control his optic blasts. The two boys were hospitalized and both suffered traumatic amnesia regarding the incident. The geneticist, who happened to be Mr. Sinister, took an interest in the boys.Who does Scott end up with X-Men?
Scott Summers and Jean Grey finally marry. During their honeymoon, they are brought into the future where they raise Cable for the first 12 years of his life during The Adventures of Cyclops and Phoenix miniseries. After helping Cable defeat the future version of Apocalypse, they are sent back to the past.Scott Summers: Class of 2014
More answers regarding scott Summers's status in X-Men: The Last Stand?
Answer 2
My memory's a bit foggy as it's been a while since I've seen the movie, but I seem to recall in the scene where Jean Grey/Phoenix come back to the mansion that she ends up telling Wolverine that she killed him.
So yes, Scott Summers is dead as of X-Men: Last Stand
Also, Xavier's consciousness is transferred into a comatose body, but they never explain how he has his normal body back in X-Men: Days of Futures Past.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Thái Huỳnh, Andrea Piacquadio, ROMAN ODINTSOV, Robert Forever Ago