Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist?

Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist? - Photo of Female Mobster Pointing the Gun on Man

The movie Arrival has an unusual kind of plot twist where

several sequences that look like "typical" flashbacks to the eye of the viewer are later revealed to be a flash-forward, that is, they happen after the main story line of the movie rather than before.

This is, in my view, an interesting twist because it goes against the expectations of the viewer who is used to that plot device.

Was Arrival the first movie to feature this trick? Are there earlier examples?



Best Answer

No.

There is a scene in They Shoot Horses, Don't They? (1969) where Robert, the character played by Michael Sarrazin, is seen being thrust into a jail cell by a police officer, even though he has done nothing to provoke such treatment. The audience is notified, later in the story, that Sarrazin's character would have indeed made choices that warrant his arrest.

There was also a TV series literally called FlashForward (2009-10) in which every character experiences a memory blackout, and each episode flashes forward to a character's future life.




Pictures about "Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist?"

Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist? - Photo of an Elegant Woman Pointing the Gun
Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist? - Photo of Detective From Behind
Was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist? - Monochrome Photo of Men Sitting in Front of Bar Counter



Does Arrival have a plot twist?

As the film's major \u201ctwist\u201d highlights, the flashbacks Louise is having of a daughter are actually experiences from her future. After the failed terrorist attack by rogue military personnel, Louise asks the heptapod nicknamed Costello about this strange little girl she keeps seeing.

What is the plot of the movie Arrival?

Arrival is based on the Nebula-winning science fiction novella "Story of Your Life" by Ted Chiang, written in 1998.

What inspired the movie Arrival?

So The Arrival is ...The Arrival is a Charlie Sheen film from 1996 that looks like this: We're talking about Arrival, which is a 2016 movie based on the short story "Story of Your Life" by Ted Chiang.



ARRIVAL (2016) Ending Explained




More answers regarding was Arrival the first movie with this plot twist?

Answer 2

I guess what makes Arrival different from other media where this has been done is that the main character refers to future events as if they were the past. It's not just a flash forward. She's actually remembering the future.

In the Westworld TV series, they often show the audience 2 different timelines and sometimes it becomes difficult to know what happens when until the last episode of the season. (This was especially true of the first season where it wasn't at all clear there were 2 timelines.) But the hosts (the robots) will often get confused about what timeline they're on, asking "Is this now?" They don't see the future like Louise, but they often can't tell if they're living a moment or remembering something from the past in a reverie.

These both contrast with something like Memento where the story is told backwards, but the characters experienced the events in the usual order. In fact, the entire premise of that movie is that the main character has trouble making memories at all.

Answer 3

I don't know if it fits exactly, but in Helix Season 2 (2015), The show start with two plots that we are made believed are concurrent

while we learn later they occurs 20 years apart.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: cottonbro, cottonbro, cottonbro, cottonbro