Was this character lying?
In the The Blind Swordsman: Zatoichi (2003) the titular character is always presented with closed eyes, therefore, everybody treats him as a blind man (hence the title).
However, towards the end of the movie, one of the villains says "A blind man like you won't slay me easily". For this, Zaitochi replies:
by opening his eyes:
Vilain: Why do you act blind?
Zatoichi: Because the blind, they sense people better!
Similarly, later on, another character says:
I knew that you could see! I knew the first time you came here.
Was he lying in those scenes (if so - why?) or was he lying through to everyone else up to that point?
Best Answer
No, Zatoichi never fakes his blindness. He is truly blind. At least that is what most people familiar with the tale of Zatoichi and the series would tell you. The character is intended to present as a weak blind man who is strong on the inside.
The Zatoichi films, not only a 2003 movie but a long running series, were first made in the 1960s, with the main character being a seemingly harmless weakling, a pushover in appearance. A masseur by trade, he wanders the country. Masseurs, both the profession and the practitioners, were known as anma/?? in Japan. Most masseurs were blind. The character's name is actually Ichi (?) and zat? (??) is an old-fashioned way to call the social class of blind men working as masseurs, acupuncturists, and lutists.
The film series' Wikipedia page has pretty detailed explanation of the character:
The character's name is actually Ichi. Zat? is a title, the lowest of the four official ranks within the T?d?za, the historical guild for blind men (thus, zato also designates a blind person in Japanese slang). Ichi is therefore properly called Zat?-no-Ichi ("Low-Ranking Blind Person Ichi", approximately), or Zat?ichi for short. Massage was a traditional occupation for the blind (as their lack of sight removed the issue of gender), as was playing the biwa or, for blind women (goze), the shamisen. Being lesser Hinin (lit. "non-people"), blind people and masseurs were regarded as among the very lowest of the low in social class, other than Eta or outright criminals; they were generally considered wretches, beneath notice, no better than beggars or even the insane—especially during the Edo period—and it was also commonly thought that the blind were accursed, despicable, severely mentally disabled, deaf and sexually dangerous.
And actually your quoted lines are pretty telling of the character. When asked if he is blind, Zatoichi replies: "Not at all." He does not mean he is not physiologically blind. He is. No doubt about it. He is saying that he is not blind in the heart and with his heart he can see clearly all the darkness in the world that he is battling. In the same vein people say "a blind heart" or "blindness of the heart". It is for the same reason another character comments: "I knew that you could see! I knew the first time you came here." meaning: "I know you could see clearly with your heart. You are a sage."
Note: It has been a long while since I saw this movie, so I am writing from memory, but I think the gist is clear.
The greatness of the character of Zatoichi lies in the fact that he comes from the lowest rung of the society, he is severely physically challenged, and he is looked down upon by almost every new person he meets. But he is strong, both spiritually and in swordsmanship. Keywords: contradiction, surprises, spirituality.
Pictures about "Was this character lying?"
How do you show a character is lying?
Screenwriters often describe lying characters movements as fidgeting, squirming or breaking eye contact. Highly-trained liars have mastered the art of compensation by freezing their bodies and looking at you straight in the eye.What is a character lie?
But what is the lie your character believes, exactly? In fiction, a character's lie is a false belief that serves as an obstacle in their life. Typically, a character's lie stems from one or more of the following elements: doubt, fear, regret, remorse, or a real or imagined flaw.What is the lie that a character believes?
The Lie Your Character Believes is the central cog in your character's arc. This is so simply because the Lie is the reason change needs to happen\u2014and therefore the reason there's a story to tell in the first place.What is the lie in storytelling?
The Lie the Character Believes But, festering under the surface, is the Lie. In order for your character to evolve in a positive way, he has to start out with something lacking in his life, some reason that makes the change necessary. He is incomplete in some way, but not because he is lacking something external.Character Is A Vital Lie
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Kamaji Ogino, Kamaji Ogino, Kamaji Ogino, Kamaji Ogino