What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo?

What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo? - Abandoned Rusty Train on a Wasteland

In the middle-end part of the movie Hugo, there is a train incident (symbolizing the 1895 Montparnasse Train Wreck) in the station. It seems pretty strange that the train incident is included in the movie, which happened at a different time than in the setting of the Hugo movie itself.

What is Scorsese trying to portray by including the incident inside the Hugo movie?



Best Answer

The train wreck is part of Hugo's dream. He has recently shown the drawing the automaton created to Méliès, who, in a state of sudden emotion, ejected Hugo from his home.

Hugo has felt that there is a part of his father's life which he can only access through repairing and understanding the origin of the automaton, and this rejection has left him reeling. This hurts all the more because even though Méliès is gruff with him, he has accepted Hugo as an apprentice, and is the closest thing Hugo has to a father figure.

He dreams of a train wreck, happening as he's attempting to retrieve the key from the track - the key that might give him a connection with his father, or perhaps more importantly access to a new father. The train wreck symbolizes that everything he's worked to resolve the mystery is crashing down, and in fact it is the key that makes him human. Without it he feels he has no place in society, and no right to happiness, as he's seen so many other orphans suffer at the hands of the stationmaster.

The reason it is that specific crash is that it originally occurred at that station, and so Hugo would have been familiar with the story, and probably have seen pictures of it. There doesn't seem to be anything particularly relevant about that accident and the film or Hugo, just that it occurred at the station the film is set in.




Pictures about "What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo?"

What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo? - Concrete ground for playing tennis and badminton
What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo? - Woman in Blue White and Black Plaid Dress Shirt and Black Pants Standing Near Blue and
What is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo? -



What does the train station symbolize in Hugo?

The train wreck symbolizes that everything he's worked to resolve the mystery is crashing down, and in fact it is the key that makes him human. Without it he feels he has no place in society, and no right to happiness, as he's seen so many other orphans suffer at the hands of the stationmaster.

What is the main message of Hugo?

Hugo reflects on how living in a world of machines drives us to find our own personal purpose and place in the world. Although it is not what would be typically classified as science fiction, Martin Scorsese's 2011 film Hugo uses a machine as its central metaphor to convey themes very intimate to humanity.

Does Inspector Gustave adopt Hugo?

Hugo awakens in a cell. He reveals everything to the inspector and is released to be adopted by Georges, Mama Jean, and Isabelle. He and M\xe9li\xe8s repair the automaton together.

Where is the train station in Hugo?

Hugo | 2011 The vast 'Parisian' train station interior was based on Paris's old Gare Montparnasse. Torn down in the late 1960s, it was reconstructed by veteran production designer Dante Ferretti in the studio at Shepperton.



Hugo (2011) - Train Crash into Station Scene




More answers regarding what is the Significance of the train wreck in Hugo?

Answer 2

Is the train crash not a symbolic reference to the first movie that Méliès sees in the fair ground of a train arriving at a station? People are so startled by the train approaching the camera that they think it is going to crash into them. Méliès, at that time a magician, is so intrigued by the ability of the movies to 'trick' the eye that he gives up magic and moves into film making. It is only later that he discovers that film is also a fantastic storytelling medium.

The train is thus a symbol of the power of film to both 'trick' the eye and to tell a story. The two themes that Méliès is most intrigued by in his own film making. And by extension I assume Scorsese too.

Answer 3

I think that it means that Hugo's life is now complete with the key as he thinks but the train wreck happens because he doesn't know what to do as George's M?lies still dislikes him though he is a bit kind to him. The dream represents the feelings of Hugo Cabret.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Loïc Alejandro, Francesco Ungaro, Adrian Dorobantu, Efrem Efre