Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival?

Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival? - Diverse coworkers shaking hands after meeting

If I was confronted with someone who could only communicate through symbols, my first instinct would be to also communicate through symbols. In fact the entire basis of many languages is pictorial (hieroglyphics, Chinese symbols). One thing I don't understand is why at no point was there any attempt to also communicate this way, aside from Louise scribbling her name on a sheet of paper in English using the latin alphabet. The instinct is so basic in humans, we've been doing it for centuries.

The movie also made the point that the Chinese tried to communicate through games even though the Chinese alphabet doesn't really exist since the language is deeply pictorial. It seems they would be better suited to communicate with these aliens than a native English speaker. Was this just a crass American stereotype about the Chinese (the Chinese are just paranoid and aggressive)?

Why was there no attempt to project symbols using a computer instead of relying on a linguist communicating through speech?

An add-on to this: was there any explanation of how the alien language allowed its speakers to manipulate time? Were the Egyptians/Chinese just using the wrong symbols?



Best Answer

One thing I don't understand is why at no point was there any attempt to also communicate this way, [using pictograms] aside from Louise scribbling her name on a sheet of paper in English using the latin alphabet.

What makes you so sure there wasn't any effort to communicate through pictograms? Firstly, the ship that Louise and her team were talking to was one of twelve ships that came to Earth. Secondly, Louise's team wasn't the first in the Montana ship - there was another before her which apparently didn't fare so well. That also implies the other eleven teams were trying things before she got involved, which may not have been discussed on screen.

It's entirely possible that pictograms were tried, and failed to procure a response. In fact, given how the aliens perceive time, it's entirely possible that they were waiting for Louise and it didn't matter what anyone tried until she... Arrived. (sorry, terrible pun.)

Consider this:

Abbot was killed as a result of the bomb that went off inside the ship. ("Abbot is in death process.") But the aliens must have known the explosion would happen. So Abbot knew this was how he would die. Yet, he showed up at the appointed time and allowed the bomb to detonate in his face-equivalent. Clearly, the aliens have stopped trying to change the future they see coming - whether they've proven time is immutable or whether they just gave in is never addressed, but the point is they don't try anymore. They saw Louise as the one who would eventually succeed in communicating with them and so they waited for her.

--

Was this just a crass American stereotype about the Chinese (the Chinese are just paranoid and aggressive)?

How does the idea of the Chinese trying to communicate through games instead of pictograms make them "paranoid and aggressive?" The Chinese didn't become aggressive until the aliens started throwing around the word "weapon" - misleading translation though it may have been. In a real-world alien contact scenario, I'm not so sure America would respond any differently.

Also, at least two classical Chinese games that I can think of include pictograms taken from their alphabet on the pieces (Mah Jongg and Chinese Chess.) So using these games and using their pictographic alphabet are not mutually exclusive.

An add-on to this: was there any explanation of how the alien language allowed its speakers to manipulate time?

No, there wasn't any explanation of how the language "works." Although, I'm not sure "manipulate" is right word. As mentioned above, the aliens don't seem too interested in trying to change what they know is coming, even when it's bad, so being able to see the future might not necessarily mean being able to manipulate it.




Pictures about "Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival?"

Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival? - Happy ethnic woman sitting at table with laptop
Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival? - Happy excited African American female laughing and gesticulating while having video calling on laptop and sitting at modern cafe
Why did the humans not communicate pictorially to the aliens in Arrival? - Photo of Women at the Meeting



How do the aliens communicate in arrival?

Banks and Donnelly research the complex written language of the aliens, consisting of palindromic phrases written with circular symbols, and share the results with other nations. As Banks studies the language, she starts to have flashback-like visions of her daughter.

What did the Chinese guy say in arrival?

The writer wasn't as keen on keeping it a secret, and was happy to divulge. As he told the audience at Fantastic Fest, the line translates to: "In war there are no winners, only widows."

What did the aliens want in the movie arrival?

Costello tells Louise that in 3,000 years, the aliens will need humans' help with some unspecified crisis, which is why they visited Earth in the first place, to teach humans Heptapod B.



First Alien Contact! Scene - ATTRACTION (2018)




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Sora Shimazaki, Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio, RF._.studio