Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents?

Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents? - Crop black businesswoman speaking on smartphone on street

I observed whole movie Enemy at the Gates twice and none of the Russian or German characters speak with appropriate accents, even though it was released in 2001.

In Goldeneye, which was released in 1995, Natalya Simonova who is a Russian character speaks in Russian accent. Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in the correct regional accents in Enemy at the Gates (2001)?



Best Answer

It was a stylistic choice by the director. In this interview with Stephen Lemons, Jean-Jacques Annaud makes it abundantly clear that as far as he's concerned, once you're immersed into the story, the accents are largely meaningless and may even detract from your enjoyment of the film. He also highlights some movie classics that followed the same path:

Some journalists have been critical of the fact that you shot the film in English, and that the main players, with the exception of Ed Harris, are British and have British accents. What's your response to that criticism?

Half of the market is an English-speaking market! If you give them actors who cannot speak English, it just doesn't play. And as a Frenchman, I can only direct in French or English; I cannot direct in Russian. There's no way you can do this movie in the Russian or German. You have to go with the original version in English. After that, you've got the choice of British, American or maybe Australian actors. I remind people that movies are made in the language of their audience. When Shakespeare did "Romeo and Juliet," he didn't do it in Italian, or even using English speakers with Italian accents. This applies as well to "Dr. Zhivago," which was set in Russia, but had English actors. It takes about five or 10 minutes to accept it, but once you're in the story, you forget that those people are English or American.

and in this interview with Ed Harris in Entertainment Weekly:

”[Director] Jean-Jacques Annaud specifically asked me not to do a German accent. A lot of times the German accent in war movies becomes a cliché – a ‘Hogan’s Heroes’ kind of deal. But I worked with a dialect coach and did a Middle Atlantic thing, a little more cultured than I myself am. A little more refined, if you will. At least I didn’t sound like I was from New Jersey.”




Pictures about "Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents?"

Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents? - Elegant diverse female business partners with documents talking on street
Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents? - Happy black businessman having video call on stairs
Why do the Russian and German characters not speak in their respective accents? - From below of delighted aged male entrepreneur in classy outfit standing on street and speaking on cellphone while laughing and looking away



Why does everyone in Chernobyl have a British accent?

Jared Harris' explanation for his English accent in the Russian role is simply that the characters were 'speaking in their own language' and therefore it made sense for the actors to use their natural accents.

Why do they not speak Russian in the Great?

Indeed, creator Craig Mazin, who is American, thought long and hard about the dialogue, telling The Chernobyl Podcast that he wanted audiences to connect with the characters on an emotional level, which is why he ultimately chose to use British accents.

Why do baddies have English accents?

The reason, as linguist Chi Luu recently explained in JSTOR Daily, is that the accent lends itself well to the particular qualities that make for a compelling movie villain, a cocktail of traits more nuanced than just \u201cpure evil.\u201d Research has shown that speaking in the received pronunciation accent \u2014 the \u201cposh\u201d ...



Trevor Noah - Some Languages Are Scary




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Ono Kosuki, Sora Shimazaki, Ketut Subiyanto, Andrea Piacquadio