Why is Jack Bauer always right, above the law and free to do what he desires, but no one else is?
The series 24 seems to contradict itself always in respect to Jack. He repeatedly seems to be acting against orders and for his personal goals, pretending to act for national security. Yet he always comes out as the hero, while others acting for their personal endeavours get punished for it, even by Jack himself. This shows in various incidents throughout the show:
In Season 1 Jack's family got kidnapped and he broke protocol/rules to go get them, when CTU got to know about his endeavors they stuck with him because he was doing it for the greater good. But the question is was he really doing it for the greater good or was it personal -- because of his family? He got away with it.
In Season 4 When Jack Bauer's lover Audrey Raines got kidnapped, he did everything to save her and chocked it up on national security and went further to save the day -- but prior to eventually saving the day, Chloe's friend the Hacker who was abducted by the terrorists was been beaten and interrogated forcefully. When Jack found him later, he was reluctant to actually save Chloe's friend and he shot the two remaining terrorists and left in persuit of the one on the run, leaving Chloe's friend, why? Because he cared about the bigger picture. BUT when the word got out that FA team are about to bomb the site that the terrorists are hosting their execution telecast, he actually decided to go irrespective of orders given to him, because of a woman. Well, he was successful and saved the day, again Jack Bauer got away with breaking rules/protocol. (Actually this happended twice, and he broke rules twice for Audrey Raines, the second time his reward was a restraining order, that was the only thing that made sense to me.)
In Season 6 - "Day 6: 9:00am-10:00am" (the season that Jack returned from China) Abu Fayed, the terrorist, demanded for Jack in return for a Hamri Al-Assad. The exchange was made and it came to the intelligence that Hamri Al-Assad was actually on the side of the government. Hamri Al-Assad agreed to co-operate with CTU so as to get his immunity from all his crimes, and he agreed, but CTU agent Curtis Manning, had a beef with Hamri Al-Assad and was not pleased with the immunity granted. He was willing to kill Al-Assad point-blank because his past involved him personally. Well, Curtis Manning had is moment and had the drop on him, but Jack (standing in for national security) told Curtis Manning not to, because doing so will go against the PRESIDENT'S ORDERS. Curtis Manning refused and Jack Bauer never hesitated to kill him, actually he made it clear that he is determined to kill him. Curtis Manning died and Jack was the hero because Curtis Manning was going against presidential orders.
Later on, the main terrorist Abu Fayed got captured by Jack and the replacement agent for Curtis Manning, Mike Doyle, who happened to be the head of field ops. While Jack was interrogating Abu Fayed by assaulting him and other brutal means Abu Fayed never broke, still maintained his posture, Jack got bored and fed up and phoned the CTU director. While he was on the phone Mike Doyle went for a shot, actually his shot was more of a persuasive approach, again Abu Fayed maintained his posture, Mike Doyle got bored and pulled out his gun, Jack intervened and told Mike Doyle to stand down... he later reached for his gun saying "I do not want to shoot you, but I will if I want to ... Drop the weapon agent Doyle". Well, Doyle responded saying something and Jack replied with "those are the orders of the Director of CTU". Again Mike Doyle wasn't able to do what he wanted because Jack demanded he follow orders.
But in Season 8 when Jack Bauer's lover (Rene Walker) got killed by the Russian, NATIONAL SECURITY, PRESIDENTIAL ORDERS, GREATER GOOD, and all those things again seemed to become irrelevant and only there to make Jack Bauer all knowing and invicible etc etc. He went against everyone - The country, his friends, national security, human morals all because of one insane/crazy woman who is willing to kill herself anytime (has tried it a couple of times, minimum one) and in the event, good people died - The bank owner of Dayna's deposit bank, courageous people proving security whether private security or national service, police men, innocent people who came in the middle of a crossfire, and at the end of the day Jack Bauer was the hero? Really?
My question is:
Am I misunderstanding or missing something? Is there an explanation for Jack being right all the time, especially in those mentioned instances? Why can only Jack Bauer not be charged with treason? If I quite recall the Chief of staff of President Taylor and another associate disobeyed the president so as to ambush Jack's team and save 10,000 Americans by giving in what the terrorists asked for, and they did, and they saved 10,000 Americans. Obviously that wasn't enough because it wasn't Jack Bauer who broke the rules and their reward was life imprisonment.
Best Answer
Unfortunately, the answer isn't, "That shit actually makes sense." What you describe covers a few tropes that often tend to converge in action, crime, and drama shows:
- The Invincible Hero Trope - a movie or show going out of its way to ensure that the protagonist wins.
- The Protagonist-Centered Morality Trope - the protagonist's POV usually influences the narration, but sometimes it gets to a point where the writer(s) are bending over backwards to make the protagonist's sense of morality the overarching, defining morality of the show's universe. In crime shows like 24, this often means that all the good-guy coworkers/superiors/etc. of the protagonist look the other way or just give him a small slap on the wrist (often with an understanding that "I really didn't mind you going against orders/protocol/what-have-you, cause you were right") when said protagonist goes out-of-line. (Usually, this stepping out of bounds ends up being the right decision, despite all odds against it.)
- These can't-be-wrong protagonists are also often morally dissonant and/or Karma Houdinis, who - as mentioned in the last trope - will often get away with pretty much anything because the story doesn't allow them to be wrong about anything (even when they screw up).
No doubt I'm missing a couple of other tropes that would fit into the typical can-do-no-wrong protagonist, but to me, those are the main ones. Now, this is not to place judgement on 24 itself - or even to say that all shows that contain these tropes are automatically bad (every so often, these tropes can be done well or are sufficiently minimized so as to not detract from the show) - but simply to say that this is such a common recipe that it often flies under the radar in popular and/or mainstream shows (24 included). You'll see it in the classic Humphrey Bogart movie, Maltese Falcon, where protagonist Sam Spade gets warned by several other characters that he needs to be careful to not let his temper get the best of him and to avoid breaching protocol, but in the end he (a) proves his rather wild theories to be correct, and (b) actually saves the day precisely by losing his temper and breaching protocol. You'll also see it in more modern TV shows like Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., where you can barely make it through an episode without a protagonist breaking rules or moral codes and ending up better for it (often while the antagonists can't catch a break, even as they make the same kinds of calls). Indeed, you'll notice it in a lot of superhero films and shows, especially ones whose heroes are vigilantes (Batman), chosen one/sole-possible-savior types (Superman - though this tends to show up more in general sci-fi/fantasy, such as Harry Potter), or simply know-better-than-all-the-authorities types (Iron Man).
Pictures about "Why is Jack Bauer always right, above the law and free to do what he desires, but no one else is?"
Is Jack Bauer an anti hero?
Bauer, Meet Byron According to Lord Byron, an antihero possesses the following general qualities: He is a Rebel \u2013 The typical antihero snubs the powers that be and lives as an individual. Jack Bauer often finds himself at odds with, and even fighting against, those in high positions, including government leaders.What happens to Jack Bauer?
Jack learned from Palmer that Dale Spalding was sent to kill him. With help from Tony, Chloe, and Michelle, Jack managed to stage his own death and he walked away with a new identity.Does Jack Bauer have a son?
Joshua "Josh" Bauer was the son of Graem Bauer and Marilyn Bauer, as well as the nephew of Jack Bauer....Josh BauerFather:Graem BauerMother:Marilyn BauerNationality:AmericanResidence(s):226 Pine Crest Road, Indian Falls, California Malibu, California9 more rowsIs Jack Bauer in 24 legacy?
So that's what we did.\u201d The \u201c24\u201d franchise returned in 2017 with spinoff series \u201c24: Legacy,\u201d which featured a new leading character played by Corey Hawkins. Sutherland executive produced the show, but did not play Bauer. The actor spoke to NME earlier this year about a potential idea for a new \u201c24\u201d series.29 Hilarious Dwight Schrute Quotes From \
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Snapwire, Anete Lusina, Matthias Groeneveld, Matthias Groeneveld