Did the bugs attack Earth?
In Starship Troopers, the motive of the humans to attack the Klendathu planet is that the "bugs" inhabitants of that planet allegedly launched a meteorite at Earth that destroyed Buenos Aires. The only evidence given is that the meteorites apparently originated in the Klendathu region of space.
But this seems a bit implausible, the bugs are never shown to do it or even to have the capability of doing it, the rocks are travelling very slowly and would surely take thousands of years to reach Earth (as well as needing amazingly good aim), and in one scene the possibility the bugs would prefer a "live-and-let-live" policy is suggested. In fact, aside from a news report and some of the characters making the claim, there is no evidence offered that it was an attack on Earth by the bugs.
Furthermore, the society is portrayed or satirised as a sort neo-fascist one, and one might not put it past the government to lie about it.
So are we, the viewers, supposed to doubt that it was a deliberate attack by the bugs or are we supposed to take that report at face value?
Best Answer
The only evidence given is that the meteorites apparently originated in the Klendathu region of space.
This is true BUT we do know that the Bugs are spacefaring since they have colonised other planets in the Quarantine Zone.
Thus although we do not know the mechanism by which the bugs transport the meteors completely across the galaxy it's not impossible that they do.
There is no evidence also that Buenos Aires was actually targeted, a meteor of any reasonable size would cause significant damage wherever on Earth it hits. B.A. was plot-chosen as it's Rico's home city
There is no evidence either way that this was a false flag operation so we can't prove it was or wasn't.
Pictures about "Did the bugs attack Earth?"
Did the bugs send the asteroid?
Not sure about the book, but in the movie, it's implied (or at least, left vague) that the bugs sent the asteroid at all. We never see them launch it, it just drifts past that ship at sub-light speed, giving Earth / other ships plenty of time to react and shoot it down.Did the bugs actually attack in Starship Troopers?
Ultimately, it was the Federation which was the aggressor, having invading deep into the Arachnid Quarantine Zone and even attacking them on their home planet of Klendathu before the war began. The war eventually concluded when Arachnid counter attacks defeated many Federal invasions of their homeworlds.Did the bugs send the asteroid in Starship Troopers?
The Bug Meteor The narrator tellingly says, \u201cthe bugs send another meteor our way.\u201d It concludes that the only way to save the solar system from the bugs is to eliminate Klendathu. While Rico is in training, cadet Carmen Ibanez flies through space on the starship Rodger Young.Did the bugs attack Buenos Aires?
In the OVA, Buenos Aires was attacked by the enemies directly. In the film, the bugs attack Buenos Aires with an asteroid.GIANT BUGS ATTACK! - Earth Defense Force 4.1 Multiplayer Gameplay
More answers regarding did the bugs attack Earth?
Answer 2
Speaking from memory (haven't watched the film from a number of years), I recall the film had a relatively strong implication that the Humans are projecting onto the bugs aspects of their own collective behavior. One of these aspects is being the aggressor in the conflict. Now, the film is presented from a conformist/mainstream Human perspective, so you won't get a subplot of questioning the official story and investigation by an intrepid freethinker - you only get messages through failures and gaps in the official Human narrative, and from the scenes you are witness too yourself. But the latter are quite limited: It's mostly Rico's perspective.
You can possibly make the analogy to a US ground soldier, sent overseas as part of the forces invading Iraq. He was told "Saddam had weapons of mass destruction", but there wasn't any actual evidence that this was the case, just unsubstantiated claims. This might not have been enough for the politically astute, but it was enough justification as far as the troops were concerned.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Artem Podrez, Artem Podrez, Artem Podrez, Artem Podrez