For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop?

For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop? - Blond Young Woman Laying on Lawn on Summer Sunny Day

I've several times wondered for how long was Phil Connors stuck in that loop.

There are the on-screen shown days which I estimate around 40. But then, Phil learns lot of stuff about the people of the town, he learns French poetry, piano, ice sculpting, etc. But there are also the spoken-about days.

The director said he'd been stuck for 10 years in total. Is that realistic? What is a better estimate? If it is not possible to answers that, what is the absolute minimum of time Phil spends stuck?



Best Answer

Per the screenwriter Danny Rubin's answer here

Allow me to jump in here. Hi everyone. As mentioned above my original intent was that Phil would live for longer than a single lifetime. That was the point of the original script: to see how a person might change if he lived longer than one lifetime (it was always about a man who could not escape life). The studio felt that the loop shouldn't last longer than two weeks. They were afraid the audience would freak out if it lasted any longer. Because my bookcase calendar (also mentioned above) was a specific record of passing time, Harold chose to remove it from the script, and in that way he could tell the studio it lasted two weeks or whatever and nobody could point to anything in the script that contradicted that. This explains why the length of Phil's incarceration strikes so many as a mystery: it was designed to be a mystery. Still, the sensibility of the characters as they progressed I think required a guiding clock, and Harold provided that. His sense was that it lasted about ten years, and I think the movie reflects that sensibility.

According to the screenwriter, there are multiple answers. The studio says 2 weeks. That's unrealistic considering the 40 or odd days we see on screen. According to him, it's over a lifetime, so 70~100 years minimum for a normal human life span. For Director Harold Ramis, a "sense" of 10 years. 10 years is long enough for a man to change and learn everything we see him learn.

But as the screenwriter says, it's open ended. There is no singular correct answer, it's to the viewer to decide.

Screenwise, Phil spent 38 days that we can see, giving us a bare minimum. Since they were very careful to leave no clues, there is nothing to say if he spent just 39 days or 1000. As he had to master piano and dance and some other skills that take years of dedication to learn, a decade seems like a good imagined minimum.




Pictures about "For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop?"

For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop? - Long Dock Under Blue Sky
For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop? - Green Tree Lot
For how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop? - A Zigzagging Road In A Mountain



How long was Phil stuck in the loop?

According to Whatculture.com, Bill was stuck in the loop for 33 years and 350 days. That means he was left repeating the same day an incredible 12,395 times. How did they work it out?

How did Phil break the loop?

Even so, the script focused much more on Phil's loneliness. He breaks the loop only after realizing that there are other lonely people and that he can do good deeds to make them happier.

How does Phil break the loop in Groundhog Day?

It is also worth noting that in the earlier draft, the original spell kept Phil in the loop for 10,000 years(ish) and that it was Rita's kiss that finally broke the curse; Phil : You want to know what's really amazing? I've been waiting for you every day for ten thousand years.



Groundhog Day lasts HOW LONG for Bill Murray?




More answers regarding for how long is Phil stuck in the Groundhog Day's loop?

Answer 2

I've always viewed this movie as a metaphor spanning a lifetime. Having frequently heard the expression, "If I knew then what I know now..." GHDay begins with Phil's self-centered, arrogant, and dismissive attitude (frequently associated with the teenage years) and grows through to caring about others and finally finding contentment in a relationship that puts his partner first.

All that said; learning an instrument, another language, apparently some medical training, along with every person, action, nuance, "gust of wind", etc...in his words, "I know everything." (to Andi McDowell at the diner); despite the director's 10 year timeline, I think it should have been more like 60 or 70.

If only we could all have such a perspective on our own lives...I suspect we wouldn't sweat the small stuff so much...or make fun of lengthy philisophical posts :p Ciao!

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Ron Lach, Pok Rie, Pok Rie, Tom Fisk