How did Andy know for sure that the tree in Buxton was still there after 19 years?
In The Shawshank Redemption, Andy told Red about his dream of the pacific ocean and at last when Andy is about to break out he told Red to visit a specific hayfield near Buxton to retrieve a package.
Now, Andy has been in prison for more than 19 years and he does not have any information about the outside world. So how was Andy so sure that the tree was still there after 19 years?
I know Andy hid that cache after he escaped from Shawshank. But how was he sure about the tree when inside the prison?
Best Answer
It is safe to assume that he figures when he went in a 100 year old tree was there and unless suddenly people decided to bulldoze the trees down indiscriminately that it was probably still there as an old tree that has survived as long as it has. At the end of the day though, he did't know if they had cut the tree down or not, he was going on faith that it was still there like it was when he went in. Its more of the symbolism of something enduring like an old solitary tree that is there year in year out and long after we come and gone.
Update
In Stephen King's manuscript, the tree occupied a field in Buxton, Maine, but in real life the scene was shot 810 miles away in Richland County, Ohio. Five years ago, lightning hit the oak and some of the tree was damaged. Jodie Snavely with the Mansfield & Richland County Convention and Visitors Bureau says the rest of the tree fell Friday due to high winds. "It's a sad day for Shawshank fans," she said. Thanks to the film, the field and tree have become an international tourist destination.
SOURCE: CNN 02/22/2016
UPDATE 2
What remained of a 200-year-old oak tree made famous by the movie "Shawshank Redemption" has been cut up and hauled away by an owner of the north-central Ohio property.
The Mansfield News-Journal reports (http://ohne.ws/2ohFpuC ) Dan Dees said last week he plans to use some of the wood to make a table. The tree was rotted in the middle when high winds knocked down a portion in 2011. It was further damaged during a storm last July.
SOURCE: MSN 04/08/2017
Pictures about "How did Andy know for sure that the tree in Buxton was still there after 19 years?"
Did Red know Andy was escaping?
Red did know the escape plan, he knew Andy had access to the Warden's dirty money, and he also knew where Andy was headed after his escape.What happened to the Shawshank Redemption tree?
The tree was at least 100 feet (30 m) tall and approximately 180 to 200 years old. It played a central role in the film's plot and was one of the most popular tourist sites connected to it. The tree was split by lightning on July 29, 2011, and was eventually knocked down by strong winds on or around July 22, 2016.What does Andy tell Red is hidden in a hayfield in Buxton Maine?
In The Shawshank Redemption, Andy told Red about his dream of the pacific ocean and at last when Andy is about to break out he told Red to visit a specific hayfield near Buxton to retrieve a package. Now, Andy has been in prison for more than 19 years and he does not have any information about the outside world.Where Did Andy tell Red to go?
Sometime later, after Andy gets out of The Hole, he talks to Red in the prison yard. He tells Red about a place in Mexico called Zihuatanejo. (God bless you.) He then makes Red promise that, if he ever gets out, he'll go to a hayfield near Buxton and dig up a big rock, and take what's buried beneath it.Shawshank Redemption / Was Andy Actually Guilty? - Overanalyzing Great Movies
More answers regarding how did Andy know for sure that the tree in Buxton was still there after 19 years?
Answer 2
Oak trees live for a long time, 100 years to 200 years or more. They can continue to withstand the elements long after the person who planted them is gone. That is why they are symbols of strength, endurance and... hope.
Also the location of the tree, Buxton is a small town of just a couple of thousand people. It is very unlikely that even a few decades later, the land on which the tree stood would have been 'developed' into a shopping complex or apartment building or houses or a parking lot etc. So, Andy made the obvious assumption that the farm and the tree and the rock wall will still be there.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Mikhail Nilov, Kat Smith, Julia Volk, Uriel Mont