In Knives Out, how did Marta get away with a certain lie without vomiting?
In Knives Out, Marta vomits whenever she tells a lie. It's an interesting quirk that makes it difficult for her to execute Harlan's plan while evading B. Blanc's suspicions. When she is in the study with Harlan, she claims that she cannot play Go because she had too much champagne. It seems the movie goes out of its way to show us that this was a lie: we see in a flashback that she had refused the champagne. This suggests that her vomiting quirk is fake, she does it whenever she wants. But this causes a contradiction: why would she vomit in the soda cup when no one was even there to see it?
Best Answer
Because Marta's lie-induced vomiting is likely a guilt-based physical reaction to emotional stimuli. She doesn't get sick because she's lying, she gets sick because she's a good person, and lying makes her feel so guilty she vomits. Telling Harlan she's too drunk to play Go wasn't intended to fool or deceive him, it was a weak excuse that she knew he wasn't going to fall for to get out of sitting down for a game she wasn't in the mood to play. There was nothing to feel guilty about, because she wasn't trying to hide anything. Just making idle protests to get out of playing the game, which was never going to work, and which she knew wasn't going to work.
Pictures about "In Knives Out, how did Marta get away with a certain lie without vomiting?"
How many times does Marta throw up in Knives Out?
The key character point of Marta Cabrera, Harlan's immigrant nurse, is that she is physiologically unable to tell a lie: if she lies, she throws up. There are four (in fact five) moments in the film when this fact is utilised.Did Marta drink champagne?
Earlier I said Marta is so free of vice that not only is she never shown having a drink, but explicitly refuses a glass of champagne. However, you will notice that on the night of the \u201cmurder\u201d, Marta says several times \u201cI had a glass of champagne\u201d as an excuse to leave.Can you throw up if you lie?
With cases of chronic vomiting, he typically asks patients whether there's a common trigger around episodes. \u201cNever, at least in my 42 years of experience, has it been brought up that it was specifically around a lie, but emotional upset sometimes can be a trigger,\u201d he said.Did Ransom stab Marta?
At the last moment, Marta vomits on Ransom, revealing that she had lied and that Fran actually died at the hospital. Enraged that he had been tricked into admitting murder and arson, Ransom attempts to stab Marta but the knife turns out to be one of Harlan's many props.Knives Out | Marta's puke scene | HD
More answers regarding in Knives Out, how did Marta get away with a certain lie without vomiting?
Answer 2
Marta vomits when she directly lies. She gets only nauseous when she conceals the truth. While remaining in the lie, she gets sicker and sicker. At the end of the movie, she was able to hold off vomiting for an extended period of time. But, while facing the person to whom she was lying, she could not hold off vomiting indefinitely.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Andrea Piacquadio, Andrea Piacquadio, Sam Lion, Helena Lopes