Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid"

Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid" - If You Judge People You Have No Time To Love Them text spelled out with pink letter tiles of famous word game against black background

You're either very brave, or very stupid

It's a common as dirt line from basically every action or drama movie ever, some examples from the top of my head would be Spooks S05E08- Agenda, Star Trek DS9 S05E23- Blaze of Glory and Red Dwarf: S06E03- Gunmen of the Apocalypse (mighty instead of very, to fit in with the western theme of the episode).

I've had a google around but I couldn't find any information on this, and surprisingly TVTropes doesn't have a page for it.

Does anyone know where this phrase came from? It must be something famous because it shows up everywhere. From those I remember the earliest is Red Dwarf in 1993, so that's the number to beat.



Best Answer

Here's a book from 1945:

The pilot was either very brave or very stupid

http://books.google.ie/books?id=TvsDAAAAYAAJ&q=%22very+brave+or+very+stupid%22&dq=%22very+brave+or+very+stupid%22&hl=ga&sa=X&ei=9Y68U9bSNoWI7AbZgYHoCQ&redir_esc=y

Experiment with Google n-gram viewer to find other/closer versions of the quote.




Pictures about "Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid""

Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid" - Open To New Opportunities Lettering Text on Black Background
Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid" - Here To Help Lettering Text on Black Background
Origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid" - Goal Lettering Text on Black Background





25 Truly SHOCKING Origins of Common Phrases




More answers regarding origin of the phrase "You're either very brave, or very stupid"

Answer 2

I think The Sea Hawk (1940) might qualify as an origin, at least in film.

You were very brave, trying to take this ship single-handed.

Thank you, sir.

Brave but stupid.

Source

I would venture to guess that something very similar was written in a book long before.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Alesia Kozik, Anna Tarazevich, Anna Tarazevich, Anna Tarazevich