So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight?

So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight? - Military Men Holding Guns Beside Concrete Corner

At the beginning of 21 Bridges Det. Andre Davis has to attend a hearing, presumably for killing on duty. He is called out for supposedly using his gun too often but he stands to it and believes he was right in every case and then says:

During the Civil War, some soldiers just kept loading their muskets without ever firing. Five or six balls loaded on top of each other. In Vietnam, only 30% of frontline infantry soldiers ever fired a shot. So, ten soldiers in battle, only three truly fighting...What do you imagine the other seven were doing?

But it is not clear to me what the answer to this rhetorical question is supposed to be. What is he trying to say with this analogy? Presumably he is one of the 30% who "truly fight", but I can't imagine that he's implying that the soldiers who didn't fight didn't do anything, rather on the contrary. But if he's trying to say they prepared for war or did their part in it, it's not clear to me how that is supporting his case or what point about his behaviour that is supposed to make.

While the funeral at the start as well as Andre's talk of justice transports a very old-testamentarian vibe and he certainly is intoduced as a man who means serious business, it is also made clear throughout the movie that contrary what everyone thinks of him he's not a hot-head driven by revenge for his father and doesn't actually kill if it isn't necessary. But I'm also unsure if that first hearing scene is supposed to guide us on the wrong track that everyone else is on about him being a "trigger" or "out for justice" or if that dialogue is already trying to fight that prejudice and show that he's a "good guy".

So what answer does he expect on that question about the soldiers who didn't fight and what point about his character and his actions is he (and ultimately the film) trying to make there?



Best Answer

I think he’s trying to call the other officers in the room the 70%. People who didn’t have to do anything passing judgement on him for doing what he felt like he had to do.




Pictures about "So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight?"

So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight? - Free stock photo of adult, army, artillery
So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight? - Men in Black Crew Neck Shirt Jogging
So what did the soldiers do who didn't fight? - People in Brown Uniform Sitting on Concrete Bench



What happens if you refuse to fight in a war?

If you're tried and convicted of failing to comply with the Military Selective Service Act, you will be guilty of a felony offense. You could be subject to a fine of up to a quarter of a million dollars, a prison term of up to five years, or both.

What did soldiers fight for?

Soldiers fight because of the other members of their small unit. Most soldiers value honor and reputation more than their lives because life among comrades whom a soldier has failed seems lonely and worthless.



US President Wants to Show Hospitality But Instead Provokes a War With Aliens




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Berendey_Ivanov / Andrey_Kobysnyn, Mikhail Nilov, Matthew Hintz, Ferdous Hasan