Was he a Nazi in The Good Liar?
In the movie The Good Liar, we are shown that Hans took on the identity of Roy and escaped to England. But it appears Hans was stationed to hunt Nazis, and may not have been one himself.
In the end Lili says that she has a piece of hair of Hans which would prove that Roy is actually Hans. Roy looks perturbed at this information.
So, was Hans a Nazi?
Edit: I get that the film is about Lili's revenge for what Hans did to her. I'm asking about a specific sub-plot. Was Hans a Nazi or not? Steven insinuates he is, but Hans(Roy) claims he is not. Do the authorities consider Hans Taub to be a Nazi? If so, where in the film do we know this from?
Best Answer
In that scene in Berlin .. Steven accuses Roy not only to be Hans but also to be a Nazi. Roy accepts that he is indeed Hans but profusely denies the accusation that he was a Nazi. Going by what he says and existence of any records that connects Hans and the Nazi's it would be fair to say that Roy (or Hans) was not a Nazi.
However ... in the present day .. if Roy is exposed as Hans Taub to the authorities, it would be the case of an Identity Theft. Roy's con and crimes would all come forth and possibly lead to his arrest. He is a murderer after all.
If you're interested - In the book .. there is a much stronger indication that Hans Taub was a Nazi. And this is how he's able to get Lili's father killed in the past. Vincent's character is shown to be a Jew and that is the reason he switches sides and helps Steven and Lili.
Pictures about "Was he a Nazi in The Good Liar?"
Who was Roy in The Good Liar?
Throughout The Good Liar, we see Roy Courtnay (Ian McKellen) and Betty McLeish (Helen Mirren) pursue a sort of courtship; one that even lasts through Betty's grandson Steven (Russell Tovey) outing him as a German translator who assumed the identity of a British officer that died while the two were hunting a Nazi war ...Is The Good Liar a true story?
The Good Liar isn't a true story, rather, it's adapted from a novel. The film is about a murderous con artist named Roy Courtnay (McKellen) who meets wealthy widow Betty McLeish (Mirren) online and sets her as his next mark.What is the story line of The Good Liar?
Although some moments aren't for the faint of heart, The Good Liar is certainly worthy of a watch. Overall, The Good Liar is a good way to pass the time on a rainy afternoon in the fall but not a film you should rush out to see. It's a calmer, gentler mystery, and maybe that's the point.THE GOOD LIAR | Trailer #2 deutsch german [HD]
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Miguel Á. Padriñán, Andrea Piacquadio, Lukas, Monstera