What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"?

What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"? - Person Holding 100 Us Dollar Banknotes

Here is the dialogue between Billy and David in Moneyball:

Billy Beane: You think you're special?

David Justice: Well, you are paying me 8 million dollars a year, so yeah.

Billy Beane: No, no. We aren't paying you. The Yankees are paying half of your salary. The Yankees are paying you 4 million dollars to play against them

What is Billy trying to say? That Yankees are paying someone else 12 million dollars instead of paying David 8 million dollars? Or that Yankees would pay David only 4 million dollars?



Best Answer

Something similar to this situation is apparently going on right now with the Yankees.

As far as I can tell, the Yankees want to trade Brian McCann but he's under contract through 2018 for $17 million a year, or $34 million total. So, the Yankees are willing to trade him to the Braves and cover half his salary in return for a few decent players from the Braves as well, which would save them $17 million over the course of two years, which is money they can then use to acquire other players.

So, based on this, it would seem the Yankees dumped him as he was an older, slower, and at the time injured and under performing player, thus a liability to the Yankees in terms of the sport as well as on the payroll, sucking up money they could likely use to land a newer, better player.

In real life Justice was first traded to the Mets, who then offloaded him to the Athletics where he spent his final season.

The deal was apparently done to dump as much of his salary as possible onto another team to free up payroll, thus the Yankees literally were paying half his salary for Justice to play against them rather than for them.

Given Justice's attitude in the film, it was Beane's way of letting Justice know he's there by their good graces alone because he fits within the new team building strategy he's using, and because if the Yankees could have just dropped him they would have, but they couldn't and instead sent him to a team that was willing to cover at least half his remaining contract's agreed upon salary. Otherwise if the Yankees had their way, they would have dropped Justice and he'd have nothing.

UPDATE: Per input from LarsTech in the comments, the Yankees could have still dropped Justice if they wanted, but evidently most contracts in baseball are guarantees, so even if they dropped him they would still owe him the remaining $8 million. Therefore, trading him and getting another team to pay at least half of that amount still freed up $4 million for the Yankees to use in signing one or more players to replace Justice, but the point of Beane noting this to Justice, I feel, is accurate albeit with a slightly more malicious intent.




Pictures about "What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"?"

What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"? - Hands Holding US Dollar Bills
What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"? - Scrabble Tiles on a Pink Background
What does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"? - Top view of delicious pieces of milk chocolate bar with filling on wooden board near heap of aromatic coffee beans and instant camera with artificial chamomiles on table



How much did Billy Beane make as a GM?

What is Billy Beane's Net Worth and Salary? Billy Beane is an American baseball General Manager who has a net worth of $20 million and an annual salary of $3 million.

Was Billy Beane a good baseball player?

He was on the bench for two World Series wins - with the Twins in 1987, and the Athletics in 1989. He completed his 148-game career with a . 219 batting average and 3 home runs. Though Beane was a highly touted prospect, his skills in high school did not translate to the Major Leagues.

What was the point of Moneyball?

The central premise of Moneyball is that the collective wisdom of baseball insiders (including players, managers, coaches, scouts, and the front office) over the past century is outdated, subjective, and often flawed.



Role Model and Leadership Moneyball




More answers regarding what does Billy Beane mean by "Yankees are paying half your salary"?

Answer 2

It's a pretty common occurrence in professional sports for a team to be responsible for part of a player's salary if they are traded midway through a contract. Alex Rodriguez was paid by the Rangers while he was a Yankee.

Answer 3

The salaries are locked in while the players are under contract. If I dump a player via waivers during the season and no one picks them up, I'm on the hook for their contracted amount for the rest of that season. If I waive a player and they get picked up, the new team pays their salary, and I don't have to pay any more.

If I trade a player to a new team, the new team picks up that contracted salary amount unless the player agrees to renegotiate the contract, which not many will do. Further complicating the matter is some players have "no trade" clauses that only allow them to be traded if they agree with the deal.

What happened was that, while they wanted the player, Justice, they didn't think he was worth $8M a year, or couldn't afford to add that to their team expenses.

The Yankees wanted to make room for another player, and didn't want to continue paying Justice $8M a year. Sometimes a team will agree to keep paying a portion of the player's salary to facilitate the trade. He's describing that the Yankees agreed to pay half of the salary Justice was under contract for, and turning Justice's "I must be awesome if you're paying me $8M" around to "not only are we not paying you that much, your old team is paying $4M to be rid of you and we're in the same league as them."

The Oakland As get a player with some value left, but at $4M per year. The Yankees make room for another player they value more, and save $4M from what they would have been paying Justice.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Alexander Mils, Karolina Grabowska, Olya Kobruseva, Ena Marinkovic