Why did the ATC operator seem like he was in trouble in Sully?
In the recent movie Sully, the junior-looking ATC operator who witnesses the ditching of Sully's plane is shown as though he is facing a disciplinary action for somehow failing to properly handle the incident, if not for failing to singlehandedly prevent the plane from ditching - of course he was cleared in the aftermath.
I thought maybe it's just sequestering after an incident to ensure an accurate record, but it definitely felt like "we're firing you for this, maybe throw criminal charges at you"-type of situation.
...but I didn't buy that because he has at least two superiors standing directly behind him throughout the entire situation and none of them directed him to do any differently in handling the situation. I'm far from being an ATC expert myself but what the film showed him to do seemed textbook.
So what was going on with him then?
Best Answer
I am not a controller, but I know people who are and were -- still not an expert though. But here are my thoughts.
It goes without saying that this was a very, very serious incident in ATC circles and many more. As soon as it was determined that an emotional event occurred on the part of the controller, he was immediately replaced. The reason for this is that controllers have to have cool, calm heads in order to do their jobs. That would no longer be possible for this controller. He was not off shift, but he was removed from controlling for the safety of all concerned.
All incidents like this will automatically generate a pretty complete investigation -- beginning with all immediate parties to the event. So some immediate things had to happen like drug testing and such. A proficient controller would not fear this because he knows he is clean. This is just a matter of course when an investigation begins.
It kinda' looked like he was being ostracized but not the case. He was simply put in a relaxing place where he can be out of the way of people that needed to continue controlling. If you recall, he was periodically visited by colleagues that were trying to console him.
Pictures about "Why did the ATC operator seem like he was in trouble in Sully?"
Did Sully meet the air traffic controller?
Harten said he first met Sullenberger in Washington about a month after the miracle landing, when both men were scheduled to testify before a congressional hearing on the flight. \u201cHe told me I did a good job,\u201d Harten said. \u201cI needed to hear that from him.Who plays the air traffic controller in Sully?
Now he is reliving those remarkable moments all over again \u2013 on the big screen via actor Patch Darragh, who plays Harten in the movie \u201cSully.\u201d Frank McKellar and 2,203 others like this.Sully (2016) - Brace For Impact
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: cottonbro, Nathan Cowley, Inzmam Khan, Andrea Piacquadio