Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery?

Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery? - Sad isolated young woman looking away through fence with hope

In The Other Boleyn Girl, the King married Anne Boleyn, Mary Boleyn's Sister.

The King was hoping the second birth would be a boy, but it was miscarried. So Anne tries to seduce her own brother George to conceive a baby boy, but he refused. Gen Parker witnessed the scene.

The King took Anne the court. The Jury gave a guilty verdict. So they imprisoned Anne for adultery and beheaded her later. However they immediately beheaded George for adultery.

Why did they behead Anne later for adultery?



Best Answer

Because it was easier than divorce.

In the times of King Henry VIII (And actually till quite recently), it was a common conception that if a woman couldn't produce a (preferably) male offspring, it was her fault. So, the logic for King is simple - if Anne didn't give birth to a boy, she was somehow faulty, the miscarriage confirmed his suspicion. So what was the logical solution? Finding another mother.

However, the king of England cannot just produce the future ruler with a maid - the child must be from a legitimate relationship with his wife AND there cannot be any doubt who is the father. So, in short - he has to get rid of his wife.

Now, King Henry is a Catholic and in Catholicism, there is no such thing as a divorce, since the marriage is considered sacred. Marriage can be annulled (made invalid) if (since we are talking about King here!) the Pope himself will agree to do so. In the case of his first wife, Catherine of Aragon, he tried to convince the Holy See that this marriage was invalid, for example by citing Levictus 20:21 ("If a man marries his brother's wife, it is an act of impurity; he has dishonoured his brother. They will be childless."). This was a long, thankless and EXPENSIVE work...

In the case of Anne, he couldn't count on another annulment and with young Jane Seymour on the horizon, he had to act quickly. So he charged his (current) wife with "treasonable adultery" and executed her (since banished/imprisoned Anne would still be his wife), making way for a new one.

It is worth pointing out that the issues with getting divorced by King Henry VIII were one of the main reasons for the English Reformation, which put the King of England at the head of the Church.

Update: As @tbrookside pointed out, Henry already was the head of the Church of England during the marriage to Anne, so he could dissolute his own marriage. However, by doing so he would alienate the still big Catholic part of the country. Since his first wife had died by the time of Anne's fall from grace, by killing her he would achieve a "clean slate" and his next marriage would be legitimate even in the eyes of Catholics, reducing the discontent in the country and increasing his support. So he had accepted Cromwell's proofs of Anne's treason.




Pictures about "Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery?"

Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery? - Teenage Girl Exposing Her Face to Sunlight
Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery? - Close Up Photography of Person in Handcuffs
Why did they arrest Anne and then behead her for adultery? - Close-Up Shot of a Person with Handcuffs



When was Anne Boleyn accused of adultery?

In 1536, England's King Henry VIII accused his second wife Anne Boleyn, who had been crowned queen in 1533, of charges including adultery, incest and conspiracy against the king.

Did Anne Boleyn commit the crimes she was accused of?

Boleyn was arrested along with five men she was accused of committing adultery with \u2014 one of whom was her own brother George \u2014 in May of 1536. She was tried first and found guilty of adultery, incest and high treason, including the charge that she planned to kill the King so she could elope with a lover.

What crime was Anne Boleyn accused of and executed for?

Anne Boleyn, Henry VIII's second wife, was found guilty of high treason by a jury of her peers in the king's hall at the Tower on 15 May 1536. She was executed by decapitation on 19 May 1536 \u2013 and is thought to have been around 35 years old at the time.



The Execution Of Anne Boleyn | Henry \u0026 Anne | Timeline




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Andrea Piacquadio, Ron Lach, Kindel Media, Kindel Media