Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear?

Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear? - Eye-doctor Checking Girls Vision with Ophthalmic Equipment

I hope you all know the Cinderella's story so I am going to begin from the part where Her Fairy Godmother magically appeared and immediately began to transform Cinderella from house servant to the young lady she was by birth, all in the effort to get Cinderella to the ball. She turned a pumpkin into a golden carriage, mice into horses, a rat into a coachman, and lizards into footmen. She then turned Cinderella's rags into a beautiful jeweled gown, complete with a delicate pair of glass slippers. The Godmother told her to enjoy the ball, but warned that she had to return before midnight, when the spells would be broken.

At the ball, the entire court was entranced by Cinderella, especially the Prince. At this first ball, Cinderella remembers to leave before midnight, losing one of her glass slippers on the steps of the palace in her haste.The Prince chased her, but outside the palace, the guards saw only a simple country girl leave. The Prince pocketed the slipper and vowed to find and marry the girl to whom it belonged. Meanwhile, Cinderella kept the other slipper, which did not disappear when the spell was broken.

Why did the Slipper not disapear?



Best Answer

Purely focusing on the 2015 version of Cinderella, the answer appears to be that it's because the glass shoes were conjured separately (and therefore made wholly of magic as part of a different spell) rather than having been transfigured from something else.

As they were an afterthought, the midnight restriction doesn't appear to have the same effect on them:

FG: "Let's have something new for a change. I'm quite good at shoes"

...

"At the last stroke of midnight, the spell will be broken and all will return to what it was before"

enter image description here




Pictures about "Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear?"

Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear? - Brown Steel Letter B Wall Decor
Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear? - Loungers Under Parasol at Shoreline
Why didn't Cinderella's slippers disappear? - Room Filled with Clothes



Why did Cinderellas slipper not disappear?

Cinderella thanks her Fairy Godmother for letting her keep them. In the live-action film, it's heavily implied that the reason the glass slippers didn't disappear was because they were pure magic and did not derive from an already existing object.

Why does the glass slipper only fit Cinderella?

This includes anyone who happens to wear the same size shoes as Cinderella. Also, since her feet are naturally small, no one's feet would swell to the same size. Finally, since she spends all day every day on her feet doing work, Cinderella's feet aren't swollen in the least. This allows the slipper to fit perfectly.

How does Cinderella have the other slipper?

Basically, they were created with a different type of spell. The Fairy GM initially used transmutation magic to change the pumpkin, mice, and everything else into what Cinderella needed for the ball. However, the last thing the GM gave her were the glass slippers, which were not a new form of something else.



Why Didn't You Stop Me?




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Gustavo Fring, cottonbro, Pixabay, Zhanzat Mamytova