Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco?

Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco? - Anonymous activist showing placard with anti violence inscription

In Almodóvar's 2002 movie "Talk to Her" (Spanish: "Hable con ella"), Benigno's crime remains ambiguous to the very end: the audience is not shown, nor his best friend, Marco, ever directly told that the author is Benigno. It cannot be another and he is also convicted in the end (modern DNA testing cannot fail - even if not mentioned, plus he is incarcerated).

I understand that the director cleverly hides the rape and direct revelation to keep ... well, let's call it the "innocence" (clean conscience) of his character, Benigno. But why aren't we told? It is clear that Marco knows it: he has no doubts with the lawyer, nor he tries desperately to show the innocence (rape culpability) of his friend.

So why does the film refuse to state the obvious responsibility, at least indirectly?

I am asking because I have no recollection (for the moment) of any other (good) movie with a (deliberate) plot hole like this, I just hope that I am missing something.






Pictures about "Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco?"

Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco? - Man in Black Hoodie Holding White and Black Gun
Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco? - Woman With Pink Lipstick and Black Mascara
Why doesn't Benigno admit his crime to Marco? - Red and White Medication Pill on Black Wooden Table



What was the crime committed by Benigno Aquino Jr?

Assassination of Benigno Aquino Jr.LocationManila International Airport, Para\xf1aque, PhilippinesDateAugust 21, 1983 c. 13:00 PST (UTC+08:00)TargetBenigno Aquino Jr.Attack typeShooting7 more rows

Why did Ninoy return to the Philippines?

As the situation in the Philippines worsened, Aquino decided to return to face Marcos and restore democracy in the country, despite numerous threats against it. He was assassinated at the Manila International Airport on August 21, 1983, upon returning from his self-imposed exile.

Who is Pablo Martinez?

Pablo Mart\xednez (Spanish pronunciation: [\u02c8pa\u03b2lo ma\u027e\u02c8tines]; La Plata, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina; 7 November 1987) is an Argentine actor, singer and model. He is known for his starring roles in the television series Casi \xc1ngeles, Supertorpe and Aliados.

How did Ferdinand Marcos died?

Mariano Marcos was a lawyer and congressman from Ilocos Norte, Philippines. He was executed by Filipino guerillas in 1945 for being a Japanese propagandist and collaborator during World War II. Drawn and quartered with the use of carabaos, his remains were left hanging on a tree.




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Anete Lusina, MART PRODUCTION, MART PRODUCTION, MART PRODUCTION