Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory?

Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory? - Top View of a Family Praying Before Christmas Dinner

In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince movie, Dumbledore asks Harry to retrieve the actual memory from professor Slughorn. By seeing the actual memory, Dumbledore became aware of the Horcruxes.

But in the beginning of the movie, we can see that Dumbledore's one hand had become black and burnt because of the curse he got from destroying Gaunt's Ring. Then we can assume that he knew about Horcruxes from the beginning of the movie. Then why did he wanted Harry to retrieve the memory so urgently?



Best Answer

You're quite right: Dumbledore already knew that Voldemort had created Horcruxes. Your confusion may stem from the fact that the word "Horcrux" isn't mentioned in the altered memory, whereas it is in the book. But there's no question that he knew about them.

What Dumbledore didn't know - and what he suspected Slughorn knew - was how many Horcruxes Voldemort had made. Two had been destroyed by that point - Tom Riddle's diary and Marvolo Gaunt's ring - but Dumbledore didn't know how many others were still out there, and the sooner he found out, the sooner he and/or Harry could set about tracking them down and destroying them.

In the original, unaltered memory, Tom Riddle raises the possibility of splitting his soul into seven pieces - one inside himself, and six inside Horcruxes. This is indeed the exact number of Horcruxes he made (discounting Harry, who he made accidentally and is arguably not a Horcrux anyway).




Pictures about "Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory?"

Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory? - Family Celebrating Christmas Dinner While Taking Selfie
Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory? - Person Pouring Wine on Glass
Why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory? - Crop anonymous child getting brown stones from white container at home



Why was Slughorn ashamed of his memory?

Given how ashamed he was of his memory of the discussion (as evinced by the fact that Harry had to manipulate him into giving him the information), Slughorn apparently believed he had given Voldemort significant information (or, at least, that he had missed the fact that his "theoretical discussion" with Voldemort wasn ...

Why was it important Slughorn return to Hogwarts?

In 1996, Dumbledore convinced Slughorn to return to Hogwarts by tempting him out of retirement with the prospect of "collecting" Harry Potter as he had so many other students, with his true goal being to learn what Slughorn had told Riddle.



The Life of Horace Slughorn (Harry Potter Explained)




More answers regarding why is it necessary to get Slughorn's memory?

Answer 2

The movie diverges quite significantly from the book in this area. The movie script of the first (edited) memory contains this dialog:

Tom Riddle: I was in the library the other night. In the restricted section. And I picked something rather odd about this rare magic. I thought perhaps, you could illuminate me. It's called, as I understand it, Hor...

Horace Slughorn: I beg your pardon? I don't know anything about such things and if I did, I wouldn't tell you. Now get out of here at once and don't let me ever catch you mentioning them again!

So its clear from the script that in the tampered memory that Dumbledore originally has, Riddle doesn't mention Horcruxes explicitly (though the 'Hor...' surely would give Dumbledore a clue).

So I believe the script writers were trying to set up the situation where Harry is used to discover both the name and the magic used and reveal the extent that it was used.

I mentioned all that because I think it makes your question about the ring relevant. If Dumbledore discovered and destroyed a Horcrux already, why does he need the memory?

It is possible that Dumbledore only knows for sure that the ring contained a powerful curse. He may have suspected that it was a Horcrux, but needed the memory to confirm this. The real memory may also contain important additional information that they could use to defeat Voldemort, so he had additional good reasons to try to obtain it from Slughorn.

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Nicole Michalou, Tatiana Syrikova