Why is Jackie against Claire's bill?

Why is Jackie against Claire's bill? - Pink and White Love Print Textile

What are or what could be reasons that Jackie as the new majority whip is against Claire's sexual abuse bill?

edit: First time, it is directly revealedto to the viewer that Jackie is against it is in Season 2 Episode 10:

(Jackie) I can't cosponsor the bill in its current form.

[..]

(Claire) Almost every woman in the House supports this bill.

(Jackie) And I can't be one of them. [...] It's because I honestly don't believe in this approach. [...] You never asked my position. You assumed.

(Claire) I can't imagine what that position must be.

(Jackie) I've served in war zones[...]

In later episodes, Jackie phones directly into a tv show to attack Megan.

(I hope the questions is not too speculative, but it seems to me that between lines there are some reasons)



Best Answer

As far as I can tell, her reason is never really explained in more detail, so we can only speculate.

As she admits to Frank she killed many people through missile strikes during her time in the military, even civilians. This haunts her, but she thinks that it could not have been avoided at the time. She did what she "had to do".

She does not seem to be opposed to protecting women in the military, but she thinks that civilian oversight is not a good idea. I guess that this is because of her experiences in the war. She knows that the things she did might have been considered murder by civilian standards and that only someone in the military "get the whole picture".

As I said this is only speculation, but that might be the reason why she is against a civilian oversight committee. It would fit with the fact that she seems to have a high opinion of the military.




Pictures about "Why is Jackie against Claire's bill?"

Why is Jackie against Claire's bill? - Unrecognizable young woman demonstrating prohibition sign showing gesture of refuse using hand and note with sign stop
Why is Jackie against Claire's bill? - Brave doctor in flying superhero cape with fist stretched
Why is Jackie against Claire's bill? - Woman with paper with cross sign





Jacqueline Durand Wants To Be An Example, Not A Victim After Vicious Dog Attack




Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Ann H, Anete Lusina, Klaus Nielsen, Anete Lusina